“First-Ballot Hall of Famer”: An Idea That Needs to Die

"I don't care if you're in the top 10 all time in receptions, receiving yards, and receiving touchdowns. You'll have to wait."

Tomorrow the Pro Football Hall of Fame in Canton, Ohio will welcome three new first-ballot members—Deion Sanders, Marshall Faulk, and Shannon Sharpe—along with ninth-ballot member Richard Dent, nominated-by-the-Seniors-Committee members Chris Hanburger and Les Richter, and contributor Ed Sabol.

Once these men are enshrined in Canton, how they got there will cease to matter. Their placards will make no mention of whether they were elected in their first year of eligibility or their ninth; there is no special wing for “first-ballot” members. The Pro Football Hall of Fame’s website makes no mention of how long it took for an inductee to be elected or for how many years a player was chosen as a finalist before the Selection Committee decided that his bust belongs in a museum in Ohio.

[Read more...]

Pavel Bure: Unjustly Snubbed from Hockey Hall of Fame

pavel-bure

On Tuesday the Hockey Hall of Fame released their 2011 inductees. The names of the hockey greats being honored? Mark Howe, Ed Belfour, Doug Gilmour and Joe Nieuwendyk.

One name struck me as conspicuous by its absence: Pavel Bure.

While I could go into great detail as to why I consider Bure a better Hall of Fame pick than either Gilmour or Nieuwendyk, I don’t find either of those two undeserving of induction. (Nobody should even dream of arguing the merits of Belfour or Howe.) So really, no ill will towards the inductees, but let’s look at the case for Pavel Bure.

[Read more...]

Will Bob Knight Attend His Indiana Athletic Hall of Fame Induction?

[Editor's Note: I am happy to welcome Joe O to the writing crew here at MSF. Joe is a native of Greenwood, Indiana and a devote Hoosier fan and grad just like me.  Not surprisingly, his first effort here at MSF deals with man that all of us from southern Indiana grew up worshipping admiring: Bob Knight.

Enjoy, and welcome aboard Joe!]

——————–

Will Bob Knight attend Indiana Hall of Fame induction?Bob Knight. The General.

Three national championships. Eleven Big Ten Championships. Olympic Championship.

Four-time National Coach-of-the-Year. Six time Big Ten Coach-of-the-Year. All-time winningest coach in college basketball history.

Naismith Basketball Hall of Fame Inductee.

This is an unbelievable compilation of accomplishments, but one is still missing: an induction into Indiana’s Athletics Hall of Fame. This seems like a no-brainer for the Indiana coach of 29 years, but if you’ve been alive the last couple decades you know about the “departure” of Bob Knight from Indiana and why it’s taken so long for this day to come.

On November 6th of this year, Bob Knight’s name will finally be added to the list.

Now that Coach Knight will finally be inducted, the next question is whether or not he will attend. This question has loomed around the sports world for a few weeks now and one thing is for certain: no one but maybe Coach Knight himself knows the answer to that question.

I can only imagine all the thoughts and questions that must be going through his head.

On one side, the administration that fired him is basically gone, but on the other hand it was a ridiculous timeline of events and sets of egos that got him canned. It’s been almost a full decade and I wouldn’t blame him for still feeling uneasy and not wanting to make the trip.

It must be like that girlfriend that got away; the one that dumped you after a couple years. There were many great moments shared and memories had, but you’ve been trying to close that chapter. Now you have that wedding or event you know she’s going to be at and you’re struggling with whether or not to go.

This is how I envision Coach Knight feeling, with so many great times and memories, but with that sour note at the end. Put yourself in his shoes for a moment and envision that car ride into campus and seeing the first couple glances of Assembly Hall. If he’s as hesitant as he seems, this would be a tough ride to make.

However, Coach Knight may also be taking the opposite approach. If there is one thing we’ve learned from Coach, it’s to expect the unexpected.

This is an enormous honor at any university and especially one with the athletic, most notably basketball, history of Indiana. Even though one of the many things that made him a great coach is he always put the students first and made coaching all about his students and not his individual accomplishments, there must still be some hidden pride in being included in the HOF. He might even see this as “getting the last word in” with those that fired him. Maybe he sees this as an opportunity to close one more door before leaving the game entirely.

Whatever Coach Knight chooses, show or don’t show, I certainly hope that he does. It’s long overdue and as a lifelong Indiana fan, I’d like to be there to honor him as he so rightfully deserves to be honored at the place where he built his legacy.

As with anything Bob Knight though, he’s his own man and he’ll do what he wants to do. Let’s all just hope we see an unbuttoned dress shirt and sweater come November 6th.

**********