
The NFL will be holding its 2011 Supplemental Draft next Wednesday. This year’s Supplemental Draft is notable because Ohio State quarterback Terrelle Pryor may or may not be eligible. (As of this writing, he is not.) Even if the NFL doesn’t clear Pryor, a team might take a chance on Georgia running back Caleb King (“might” being the operative word), who is academically ineligible to play in Athens in 2011.
Unlike the regular draft, where teams pick a player whenever their turn comes up, teams in the Supplemental Draft bid on players using their draft picks for the following season. For example, say the Cleveland Browns decide that Terrelle Pryor would make a nice back-up to Colt McCoy and bid their third-round pick in the 2012 NFL Draft. Then, say that the Cincinnati Bengals decide to out-Ohio their division rivals and bid a second-round pick on Pryor. The Bengals would get Pryor and lose their second-round pick in the 2012 draft. The Browns would move on as if nothing had happened.
The NFL established the Supplemental Draft in 1977 for the benefit of players who, for one reason or another, didn’t register for the regular draft. Once upon a time, players could only enter the NFL Draft if they had graduated from college or had exhausted their college eligibility. Several players who graduated early, but not in time to register for the regular draft, entered the Supplemental Draft. Nowadays most players who enter the Supplemental Draft have been declared ineligible for their senior seasons, usually for academic or behavioral issues.
Since its inception in 1977, 40 players have been taken in the Supplemental Draft. Only a handful have made meaningful contributions to NFL franchises. The 40 Supplemental Draft selections have 16 Pro Bowl appearances between them. Cris Carter is responsible for half of those.
Here are the 12 best players ever taken in the Supplemental Draft.


