The Shockers Got Screwed

Considering Wichita State went undefeated for more than four months and did everything asked of them (beat five tourney teams non-conference, actually played road games) …

While Arizona lost two games the final week, four overall, in a conference that’s probably not among the three best in America …

Why did the NCAA Selection Committee give the Shockers the most brutal bracket? 


Gregg-MarshallThe New York Post, never a paper to mince words, believes the 35-0 Shockers were screwed. And there’s really no debate.

Let’s quickly examine the evidence:

To reach back-to-back Final Fours, Wichita State must play the preseason No. 1 team — Kentucky — this afternoon.

If WSU gets by Kentucky, the MVC Champs play the defending national champions Louisville — a team many felt could’ve been a top seed, as they played as well anyone the final month — 115 miles from their old Kentucky home.

Should the Shockers win their remarkable 37th consecutive contest in a virtual road game, WuShock likely plays Big Ten champ Michigan, who probably should’ve been a No. 1 seed and was national runner-up in last season.

The hardest road in history?  The boys from southern Kansas deserved better.

Arizona, meanwhile, plays a West Coast conference team tonight, and with a win, takes on an offensively-challenged San Diego State, followed perhaps by a Wisconsin team who barely edged a No. 7 seed before a home crowd. If not the Badgers, then the ‘Cats play Creighton or Baylor in a game just 450 miles from the U of A campus.

As evidenced most years, the Selection Committee has a bias toward major conference teams while smaller schools get the shaft. Amazingly, results don’t always matter either.

Like Butler, George Mason, Virginia Commonwealth and others before them, Wichita State succeeded against all odds last year. On the contrary, teams like Duke and Syracuse continue to get preferential treatment based upon reputation over performance.

Duke lost in the first round for the second time in three seasons Friday and has only reached one Final Four the past 10 years. Syracuse, who reached only their second Final Four in nearly two decades in 2013, was also dumped by a “mid major” last night.

Unfortunately, memories are short.

Underachieving, overrated conferences like the ACC continue to benefit from a media (mainly ESPN) stacked with their alumni, and a committee looking not to reward guts and success, but rather money and power.

As a devout capitalist, I never thought I’d write those last lines, but I also never thought I’d be proven correct nearly every spring.

It doesn’t make me happy; it makes me less interested in college basketball.

And that’s the biggest shame.



About AJ Kaufman

A former schoolteacher and military historian, A.J. now works in public relations. As an MSF columnist since 2009, he supports anything baseball-related. Raised in San Diego, A.J. has since resided in numerous parts of America, including Colorado, Florida, Indiana, Maryland, Minnesota, Nebraska, New York, Ohio and Washington State. After departing the coasts in 2005, he's traveled the back roads of all 50 states and prefers the Heartland. Married to Maria, A.J. is the author of three books and enjoys reading presidential biographies.

Comments

  1. AAC is a ‘major’ because they get an automatic major bowl bid in football. Don’t let facts like the football conference is garbage get in the way of that.

    • AJ Kaufman says:

      True, though hardly the point of the article. Wichita State shouldn’t have been given this draw. They earned better. Period.

  2. Darrell Ashworth says:

    Arizona has been buying hookers for the committee since back in the Lute Olson days.

  3. Agree. Agree. Agree. No reason UK should’ve been an 8-seed. What’s killer is the committee basically said that, based on their “S-curve”; Louisville was the 15th best team going in, and UK was the 31st best team…while UMass (?!) was the 23rd best team. Ridiculous. I don’t know if it was a conspiracy…it’s difficult to figure out exactly what the alternatives would’ve been for the committee with first round matchup restrictions (i.e. no intra-conference or reg season rematches in 1st round); but more of an effort should’ve been made to consider the fairness…

    ….actually it’s not so difficult: Syracuse and L’ville should’ve swapped, along with Kentucky and Texas (with K-State swapping regions with GW to solve the intra-conference Big 12 matchup issue). Also swap Michigan and Villanova (WAY overrated IMO…didn’t deserve regional pickings there. It’s not a requirement for an east school to play in east region if top 4 seed..although they try to do it if bracket integrity is still kept)

    Basically you would’ve had the following match ups in 2nd round:
    Midwest: Wich St-Texas in 1-8. Syracuse-SLU in 4-5. Winners facing each other…..also Villanova-Kentucky in 2-7 matchup.
    South: Louisville-Dayton in 3-11. KU-Stanford in 2-10. Winners facing each other.
    East: Michigan-UConn in 2-7 matchup(winner facing UNC-Iowa St).

    I don’t know ANYONE who would have an issue with this. Based on how the season went + how the teams were performing via “eye test” – this would’ve been a completely fair and balanced bracket. And I believe scheduling criteria would be met.

    • AJ Kaufman says:

      Perfect comments. Nothing to argue there. The Committee seeks money and ratings, as does the elite (coastal) media. They wanted WSU gone, and they made sure it happened as quickly as possible with UK as an 8 and other questionable seeds/brackets. This year was the most questionable bracket set up in my lifetime.

      • 1. code quantum=> le must, chaque épisode était différent, on ne pouvait pas se lasser !2. buffy contre les vampires=> qusu-qro;e&tsce que j’ai pu me marrer avec cette série.3. lost=> normal, sur une île déserte Série très addictive, mais surtout ne manquer aucun épisode !4. les simpsons=> toujours du pur bonheur5. les experts=> incontournable

  4. Mark Henderson says:

    I agree that KU was definitely better than an 8th seed, especially proving that to the biased selection committee in the SEC final, taking Florida to the wire. Florida and Wichita St. deserved the most respect in the bracket for their success during the season, and just based on the ‘eye test’. The tournament will be a lot better once the selection committee throws out their love affair with the East coast teams, the ACC, and the Big 10. Don’t assume they are the ‘power’ conferences. Look how the SEC has disproven their bias with their two selections and one ‘play-in’ team. (Don’t even get me going on how our third team had to play an extra game to get in.). I loved watching the Shockers play. They deserved a better fate.

    • AJ Kaufman says:

      Thanks, Mark. You are correct about the SEC, Wichita State, etc.

      As to: “The tournament will be a lot better once the selection committee throws out their love affair with the East coast teams.”

      Won’t occur. The media is based in the northeast and has a vested interest in their bias. I know these people, and they know no better. Most ESPN employees, for example, attended Duke, Maryland, UNC or Syracuse. Some Northwestern, but that’s immaterial. This is why most wise sports fans avoid ESPN these days, but they have an influence on CBS and the Committee sadly. (And FYI, plenty of Duke grads and east coasters calling games or in studio for CBS/TNT/TBS this week too).

      Facts and results won’t change their minds and will be forgotten by next March.

  5. I have exactly what info I want. Check, please. Wait, it’s free? Awemsoe!

  6. Very valid, pithy, succinct, and on point. WD.

  7. Hmm is anyone else having problems with the images on this blog loading? I’m trying to find out if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog. Any feed-back would be greatly appreciated.

  8. Many recognition for creating the effort to discuss this, I stroke solidly regarding this and enjoy studying a great covenant more proceeding this subject. If realistic, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your website with a enormous pact added info? It’s truly effective representing me.

  9. Ah et je sais que j’ai déjà fait ma commande au père Kongfuzi mais si il vous reste une affiche de Wolves in the throne room je suis preneur ! Merci les gars !

  10. Hej!!Dessa gick hem hos oss stora och även hos sonen.. Dessa skall göras fler gånger, de belv super goda, och de var fortfarande super goda dagen efter :)//Maria

  11. clube que depende de MARKETING pra isso já é porque ali tem. e no gremio tem sim. essa campanha também não sei se é muito boa. muito artificial pro meu gosto. talvez se os proprios jogadores negros do elenco (nao me lembro nenhum agora) saissem em defesa do xuxinha seria melhor. e se a propria torcida recriminasse na hora esta posição, que não é de um grupo nazista, mas de grande parte da torcida do gremio. basta conversar com qualquer gremista que voce logo vai ouvir algo relativo a isso.

  12. No one knows when the end will come–so we must always be ready. Good thing Camping was wrong. I dont think I could have put up with an eternity filled with “I told you so”

  13. I used to be very happy to seek out this internet-site.I needed to thanks to your time for this excellent read!! I positively having fun with every little little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to take a look at new stuff you weblog post.

  14. What a pleasure to meet someone who thinks so clearly

  15. De url naar de wervingswebsite die gemaakt is zou natuurlijk niet misstaan. iedereen is nu nieuwschierig! (verder is het goede linkbuilding, wat weer belangrijk is voor hoog in google komen)

  16. Do you mind if I quote a few of your articles as long as I provide credit and sources back to your webpage? My blog site is in the very same area of interest as yours and my users would genuinely benefit from some of the information you present here. Please let me know if this ok with you. Regards!

  17. Hi MichaelI have a problem with my AP300′s picking up via a layer 3 network. The ap’s work connected via level 2 with no problem. They are connected to a switch where thin client workstations and pc’s and laptops etc all are working via DHCP with no problem. On the DHCP server i have setup the 189 option but still nothing! Do you have any advice anything is welcome.ThanksRobert

  18. I am only commenting to make you be aware of of the cool experience my child enjoyed using yuor web blog. She even learned such a lot of pieces, including how it is like to possess an excellent giving style to let other folks with ease understand a variety of complicated matters. You truly surpassed readers’ expected results. I appreciate you for showing these beneficial, trusted, revealing and in addition unique tips on the topic to Janet.

  19. Gresit ! aceste idei provin in cel mai bun caz din exasperarea inaltilor functionari de stat in legatura cu subdezvoltarea tarii, care exasperare? Pana acu au privit satisfacuti prabusirea azi brusc ii apuca activismu pro. Ntz. Esasperarea lor este stimulata … ine 2014 si ei pregatesc oferta !!

  20. Wait, I cannot fathom it being so straightforward.

  21. Olá pessoal, também tenho timidez sempre que ouçam as pessoas conversando fico querendo ter o que falar mas não consigo o mesmo é aproximar de quem gosto. Graças a Deus sou Cristão tenho 22 anos nunca namorei cresci no berço evangélico.

  22. ¿Sabes que cuando alguien viene a Madrid no puede marcharse sin comerse un bocadillo de calamares? ¡qué ricos! Pero seguro que no tanto como los que tú has hecho con ese rebozado, que sería la envidia de cualquier bar de tapas de por aquí.Ya he ido a dar mi enhorabuena a la ganadora, y ahora a ti por conseguir por fin unos calamares como los de tu madre. Ahora te va a tocar a ti hacérselos, ya verás, je je.Un besito.

  23. Coucou Grenouillette ! Je suis ravie d’avoir fait ta connaissance sur le salon !!! Je vois que tu n’as pas chômé pendant les 3 utres jours ! Rah lalal des jolies pages comme je ne saurait jamais en faire !!! (mais dit moi, elles sont où les fleurs ? MDR !)Gros bisous et bonjour à bob’ ;)Elo

  24. 01 Sep 23, 2012 9:53 nume Ce nashpa e sa cauti chestii COOL! Deja cand transformi simplitatea in chestie COOL… ai si pierdut-o! Ca sa nu mai zicem de faptul asta al dumneavoastra de a ne invita pe noi sa purtam ce poarta Dorin Stefan….

  25. Way to go on this essay, helped a ton.

  26. Hi Karen, I didn’t laugh at Ross and Ed. I am rather cranky these days, but I think that is child abuse. After the 3rd fall, that mom should have chucked that pony and kept her child safer. but to make a video and have fun showing the pony dumping her child again and again is really too much for me. I hope that child can survive such rotten parents. He is a cute little kid. I couldn’t believe it when he was being dragged! what kind of demented parent thinks that is funny?

  27. “And postgraduate education is a lot more than just the odd PhD.”No, but there are already far far more PhD students out there than there are academic jobs. I haven’t seen ANY funding proposals for universities that feature money for more teachers and researchers. Lots of cash for more buildings though.

  28. hi can i ask you if i want uses iphone and line how much i must pay for month ..please i need to know.and must have first payment or not?if have how much?[]

  29. 1. Reklama caÅ‚kiem przyjemna, tylko te dwie brÄ…zowe plamy, na koÅ„cu .. to jej pot ?:))Agnieszka naturalna.2. ProszÄ™ podać przykÅ‚ad billboardu z twarzÄ… bez retuszu ?:) Z retuszem skóry przede wszystkim? Ja nie znam takowego.

  30. Leroy September 28, 2012 Bernie – you provided an informative and humorously entertaining performance at the ACGSC in Fort Leavenworth, KS. Your personal DUI lessons learned and suicide/care-provider experiences with your twin brothers displays your strength and character. You re-emphasized the importance of simultaneously taking care of self and others. Thank you again for a great training session and performance.

  31. It’s good that somebody did muster enough courage to write upon a subject which Muslims mostly overlook. I’ve personal accounts of some caste based preferential treatment. It’s time that the Indian Muslims address the issue. Thanks Ayub for the review!

  32. A few things i have observed in terms of personal computer memory is that often there are specs such as SDRAM, DDR or anything else, that must fit in with the technical specs of the mother board. If the personal computer’s motherboard is pretty current and there are no main system issues, updating the memory literally requires under a couple of hours. It’s among the list of easiest laptop upgrade techniques one can visualize. Thanks for spreading your ideas.

  33. Love the clogs! Amazing! And so cheap! English charity shops seem to get more and more expensive by the day, average spend is around £5 a pair although I clocked a new record today of £30 for a pair of heels. Outrageous. :(

  34. Yah, I'm a gun owner, and not a shooter. I do, however, believe that the most elementary skills of operating a gun are accessible to anybody who cares to learn them.Or is not so arrogant that he is not willing to have them taught to him. (See my comment above about NTs, those annoying monkeys)

  35. Toptable? That’s not dirty, it’s perverted.I’ve never really looked at their offers before and there are actually some pretty good ones, places like Foliage and Pattersons are on there. I will keepy a wary eye on it and could well be lowering my filth threshold accordingly

  36. A1528Vieux passe-temps que la lecture des dicos, je lis mes dicos comme d’autres lisent le journal ou sacrifient leur temps aux mots croisés, autre saine passion que cette dernière. Je lis et je prends note dans des cahiers d’écoliers, un mot est toujours disponible , il ne meurt jamais et se laisse prendre comme une fille.Agouant ne doit rien à un lapsus .Vous me permettrez de revenir sur les « progrès » de l’humanité, mes guillemets vous donnent une piste…

  37. Yay Kazz! I love your work, and yes I salivate and lick my lips when fabric shopping. Love reading your blog – Too funny! Don’t change.

  38. Hahahaha OMG it is a long book. I can barely get through 10 nursery rhymes with the toddler before I find myself speeding through it and getting it over with. Great illustrations!

  39. Wow, I am impressed with your purchase of spelt grain. How will you grind it? I adore spelt flour and use it as a replacement for wheat flour in lots of recipes.If you click on the link where I say “I do too” it will take you to my mincemeat recipe.But here is the link too . Mincemeat is a mixture of dried fruit, apples, nuts and suet (it could be vegetable suet if you want to serve the mince pies to vegetarians) and is a delicious Christmas treat in a mince pie.

  40. you are in point of fact a excellent webmaster. The site loading pace is amazing. It kind of feels that you are doing any unique trick. In addition, The contents are masterwork. you’ve performed a excellent activity in this subject!

  41. David Craver (PHOTOGRAPHER) – I cannot thank you enough either:) We still talk about how fun your wedding day was. Sarah and Jenna still make comments about how in love you and Terry are too! I was proud as a consultant to show off your wedding. Your wedding was truly one of my highlights of the year! *** David ***

  42. August 8, 2012 mmmm such a fan of bbq chicken!! we actually havent grilled yet this summer…because its too dang hot out there!Kat recently posted..

  43. A wonderful job. Super helpful information.

  44. I find it can be so challenging to try to stay on a New Year’s resolution based diet! I really find it has to be a lifestyle change – you almost can’t think about doing it. You just gotta do it! LOL : ) Great advice, Chef Donna!

  45. 5126I think that is among the so much important information for me. And i’m happy reading your article. However want to remark on some general issues, The web site style is perfect, the articles is truly nice : D. Excellent process, cheers

Speak Your Mind