Chris Davis, In Midst of Breakout Season, Has One Glaring Area For Improvement

[Editor’s note: While working on this analysis of the Baltimore Orioles‘ chances of contending into September, Andrew put together a section on Chris Davis. It’s so long and such in-depth statistical analysis that we’re just breaking it out as its own article.]

Chris Davis has finally begun to translate his well-documented minor league success into his big league game.

While Davis’ 25+ home run pace is in line with his career averages, his current .260 batting average has been a welcome surprise for the Orioles.


Analyzing Davis’ statistics, there is certainly reason for optimism: Davis’  batting average on balls in play is .329, which, although high, is absolutely sustainable. When Davis hits a line drive or a fly ball, he gets a hit better than 50% of the time (.511 avg), and that statistic is not a mistake–when Davis hits the ball squarely, he hits it hard. Even more encouragingly, since Davis is a power hitter a good majority of his balls in play will inevitably be fly balls and line drives.

The problem with Davis this year however (as has been his problem throughout his career), is his pathetic strikeout-to-walk ratio.

Currently, Davis strikes out 5 times for every 1 walk–and Davis strikes out a lot. His 108 strikeouts this year lead the Orioles by a comfortable margin, and keep in mind, this is an Orioles team that includes Mark Reynolds, one of the most prolific strikeout hitters in Major League history.

A further analysis of Davis’ statistics reveals another interesting trend: When facing a pitcher for the first time in a game this year, Davis is hitting .285 with and OPS over .800. However, when Davis is facing a pitcher who he already has batted against in a game, his average drops down to .230.

The reason for this disparity is that pitchers throw Davis fewer strikes in his subsequent at bats against them–in other words, they pitch around him. While this should lead to more walks for Davis, it accomplishes exactly the opposite–it leads to more strikeouts because Davis continues to swing, whether the ball is down the heart of the plate or in the dirt.

Davis is currently swinging at 38.6% of pitches he sees outside the strike zone, which is over 8% greater than the league average. Perhaps more troubling, Davis is only making contact with 55% of the non-strike pitches that he swings at, which is 12% below the league average. Thus Davis swings at more balls than the average MLB player and makes contact with a lower percentage of those pitches than the average MLB player. It should therefore not come as a surprise that Davis is among the league leaders in strikeouts.

Luckily for Davis, there is a relatively simple solution: stop swinging at bad pitches.

If Davis wants to sustain any long term success in the major leagues, he must adopt a much more selective approach at the plate. Davis’ swing is fundamentally sound (it’s actually a thing of beauty), and his consistently high BABIP suggests that there is no problem with his timing or vision. Rather, the problem is with his selectivity.

By narrowing the zone in which he swings at pitches, Davis will undoubtedly accrue more walks and strikeout less. More importantly, he will force pitchers to throw him strikes, which will allow him to do what he does best: hit the ball hard.

Whether Davis will be able to adopt a more selective approach in the future remains unclear. However one thing is for sure–his future absolutely depends on it.

Davis is arbitration eligible for the first time in 2013 and under team control until 2016. If he can figure out how to become more selective, he could and should become a building block of the Orioles offense for years to come.

Under this scenario, the Orioles could buy out the rest of his arbitration-eligible years and sign him to a long term extension at a very reasonable rate. However, If the Orioles don’t see him as a long term fit, it is possible that they will try to move Davis. perhaps this coming off season, when he is at his peak value.

As an Orioles fan, I am rooting for Davis to become a face of the franchise, but as a more arbitrary observer, I realize that such an arrangement may not be in the best interest of the franchise.


The source I used for the statistics was

About Andrew Schwartz

Andrew Schwartz is a Maryland native, who has also lived in Rochester (NY), New Orleans, and San Diego. Schwartz has a Bachelor's degree from the University of Rochester, a Law degree from Tulane University, and probably used Degree deodorant this morning. Despite playing in numerous fantasy football leagues for over a decade, Schwartz believes the television show "The League," would be much better if it excluded all fantasy sports references. While Schwartz's favorite sports movies are "Warrior," and "The Natural," he suggests that you watch the 1991 college football comedy "Necessary Roughness" at your earliest convenience. You can email Schwartz at

Speak Your Mind