Fantasy Baseball 2012 Strategy and Advice: Breaking Down in Tiers – Catchers

Tackling fantasy drafts leaves owners with many options and decisions at virtually every position. The bare bones key to success lies in being able to snap up the undervalued guys who will produce the same exact stats as guys who are being drafted at a higher price.  Remember, the standings only look at the numbers, not the name attached to them.

This brings us to our series on fantasy baseball tiers for the 2012 season.  When organizing each position into tiers, it enables owners to see which players should produce relatively the same statistics, and easily spot under/overvalued players in each tier.  Tiers are a simple solution for finding bargains in every draft.


Mike Napoli is an elite catcher. (Photo by Red3biggs via Wikimedia Commons)

To begin, let’s define the tiers that we will classify each position by:

  • Elite: These players can be the foundation for your fantasy team and are the best players at their positions. Albert Pujols and Matt Kemp are examples of elite players that will help carry your team to a fantasy title.
  • Valuable: Cannot go wrong with this group. These solid players, who will produce for your team, are dependable and can help win a fantasy title for you. A notch below the elite, the valuable players nevertheless are very productive.
  • Solid: These players will put up numbers and can even lead in certain categories. However, inconsistency and poor performance in other categories will hurt your fantasy team at times.
  • At Your Own Risk: Limited production at this level, this group either struggles to get at bats on a regular basis or are the least producing players at their position. Proceed with caution and do your research.  The bargains found here are truly the ones that can drive a championship season. This group also includes younger players with potential.

Catchers: Elite

  • Carlos Santana
  • Mike Napoli
  • Brian McCann

You will be in good shape with any of these three elite catchers. Santana is potentially the top catcher in both leagues but needs to improve his average, which we expect this season. Napoli really came in to his own with a potent Texas offense and looks comfortable in the Rangers lineup for the next few seasons. McCann is the best hitting catcher in the National League and with more at bats may hit closer to 30 HR.

Best Bet: Mike Napoli

Catchers: Valuable

  • Matt Wieters
  • Joe Mauer
  • Miguel Montero
  • Buster Posey
  • Alex Avila
  • Yadier Molina

Can Mauer return to his MVP-like form? Getting playing time at 1B will help, and you get the feeling Mauer has a big comeback year in him for 2012. Will Wieters take the next step as the highly touted young catcher? Is Posey able to bounce back from injury? This group will solidify your catching position and may possibly feature several “elite” statuses before the season is completed.

Best Bet: Matt Wieters

Catchers: Solid

  • J.P. Arencebia
  • Geovany Soto
  • Chris Iannetta
  • Russell Martin
  • Devin Mesoraco
  • Kurt Suzuki
  • Wilson Ramos
  • Jesus Montero
  • Miguel Olivo
  • Jarrod Saltalmacchia

These are starting catchers and will give your team production from the catcher position. Arencibia is a powerful slugger who will help your HR category while hurting your average. Martin and Olivo will hit for less power but are capable of 6-8 SB a year.

Best Bet: J.P Arencibia

Catchers: At Your Own Risk

  • Ryan Doumit
  • Ramon Hernandez
  • Carlos Ruiz
  • A.J. Pierzynski
  • John Buck
  • Nick Hundley
  • Ryan Hanigan
  • Jesus Flores
  • Jonathan Lucroy
  • Rod Barajas
  • Branyan Pena
  • Wilin Rosario
  • Chris Snyder
  • Salvador Perez
  • Robinson Chirinos
  • Hank Congar
  • Josh Thole
  • Yorvit Torrealba
  • Ryan Lavarnway
  • Tyler Flowers
  • John Jaso
  • Francisco Cervelli
  • Ivan Rodriguez
  • Gerald Laird
  • Jason Castro
  • Victor Martinez
  • Travis D’Arnaud
  • Jake Fox
  • David Ross
  • Kelly Shoppach
  • George Kottaras
  • J.R. Towles

Several starters are included in this group but have proven not to put up productive numbers in a full season. These are prime choices to be your back up catchers. Be sure to grab a starter from the first three groups above; do not wait for any of this group to be your No. 1 catcher.

Best Bet: Nick Hundley

About Jim McGrew

A lifelong Chicago sports fan, Jim enjoys playing, writing about and watching sports. He can be reached at or on twitter at @MySports1.
Jim lives in the Chicago area and is married with 2 children.


  1. I’m in a 10 redraft and this is my first time ever of starting 2 catchers. Is it a must to get one of the top 4-5 guys then?

  2. Jim McGrew says:

    No, it’s not a must and I would recommend not drafting a catcher too early that would be better spent on top tier guys at other positions. The catcher position can be unreliable and I would suggest you make sure you get a starting catcher from at least the “Solid” category for your #1 pick, then a low end catcher in later rounds. Getting Arencibia or Soto around rounds 11-12 is possible, then a AJ Pierzynski or sleeper Salvado Perez (Royals) in round 20-22.
    Good luck to you!
    Jim McGrew

  3. Jim McGrew says:

    Check that on Salvado Perez…SURPRISE, Ariz. — Catcher Salvador Perez was on crutches in the Royals’ clubhouse Sunday morning, heading for what will be a daily destination for him — the training room. Perez has launched his rehabilitation work after knee surgery on Friday for repair of a torn lateral meniscus. The initial estimation is that he’ll be out for 12 to 14 weeks and might not be ready for Major League action until around the All-Star break.

  4. Unfortunately, not alll of those courses are worth the money that you will pay
    for them.

  5. Only the Anxiety Wrap has rear leg straps that create rear-finish
    consciousness to target stress factors within the hindquarters the place canines typically hkld

  6. Inhaúma: Se nome já é fеio, imagina bairro… seu maiߋr marca turístico é um
    cemitério onde peгvertidos se encontram em direção a noite para fazer sexo.

  7. Wordekemper said the board has accredited the acquisition of
    nursing home mattress licenses needed to function the ability.

  8. For internationwl sourciung the web site should be integrated to business to business, enabling businessmen luxury to do clmpany aas well as
    do import & export in their own area.

  9. Hurrah! Finally I got a webpage from where I be able to truly get useful data regarding my study
    and knowledge.

  10. The Welcome Home Companies package consists of a FREE Evaluation and services up to six hours.

  11. If some one desires to be updated with newest
    technologies therefore he must be visit this web site and be up
    to date daily.

  12. Martial arts coaching equipment for speed, strength and stamina.

  13. Does your website have a contact page? I’m having problems
    locating it but, I’d like to send you an e-mail. I’ve got
    some recommendations for your blog you might be interested in hearing.
    Either way, great website and I look forward to seeing it grow over time.

  14. Jeffrey Saletnik, John Cage and the Task of the Translator,
    ” Art in Translation 4, no. 1 (March 2012): 79 (ill.).

  15. This low-volume” oof frequent panic thast follows
    a panic attack is knmown as generalised anxiousness dysfunction (GAD).

  16. I am not certain the place you’re getting your information, however good topic.
    I needs to spend a while learning more or working out more.
    Thank you for fantastic information I was searching for this information for my mission.

  17. I am impressed with this website, very I am a
    big fan.

  18. Not only is it effortless to discover motels in a hurry, but when matters modify like they generally do it is really quick to make adjustments to your bookings.

  19. Wonderful post! We are linking to this great article on our site.
    Keep up the great writing.

  20. A person necessarily lend a hand to make critically articles I’d state.
    That is the first time I frequented your web page and to this point?
    I surprised with the research you made to create this particular submit incredible.
    Fantastic job!

  21. Becoming an affiliate marketing advertiser quick to do when the write mechanical on line blueprints are put write
    in front of you Quyen Buy standard sweets at a value of around $1 Quyen means massive Residual Income that will support them for the Quyen you’ll finally be wanting to speak Italian Acls pretest
    2016 answers pdf there turn out to be a lot of online guitar courses Quyen Testinside JN0-321 study guide resources can establish most valuable when facing the challenging JN0-321
    test Quyen

  22. It credit is clear, avoiding ownership disputes and competing claims.

  23. Achieving high growth over sustained periods, credit monthly payments.

  24. Hi there! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any problems with hackers?
    My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up
    losing months of hard work due to no backup. Do you have any methods to stop hackers?

  25. It iis tɦe best time to make some plans for the ⅼong
    rᥙn and it’s time to ƅe Һapⲣy. I’ve read this publish and if
    I coulɗ I wish to cunsel you some attention-grabbіng issues oor tips.
    Perhaps youu could wrіte next articles referring to thіs аrtіcle.
    I desire to learn more tһings approximately it!

  26. Hi, I do think this is an excellent site. I stumbledupon it ;) I may come back once
    again since I bookmarked it. Money and freedom is the greatest way to
    change, may you be rich and continue to guide others.

  27. supplémentaires messages comme celui-ci .

  28. Luckily, the game can now be offucially downloaded by folks
    living in the USA, on both iOS and Android.

  29. Alll this being said, it hasn’t been smooth sailing for thos fanatical Pokémon Go players who’ve already started using the game.

  30. Go through the process of creating an Apple ID and select ‘None’ in thhe Billing menu and add a US, Neww Zealand or Australian address.

  31. Annd sitting down down though posing for pictures, he was taller
    than workforce president/coach Stan Van Gundy.

  32. thank you for this post, I am a big fan of this site
    would like to keep updated.

  33. You got a very wonderful website, Gladiola I discovered it through yahoo.

  34. Yes! Finally something about ig.

  35. Hi colleagues, how is everything, and what you want to say on the topic of this
    post, in my view its really amazing in favor of me.

  36. Hello just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The text in your
    article seem to be running off the screen in Ie. I’m not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with internet
    browser compatibility but I thought I’d post to let you know.
    The design and style look great though! Hope you
    get the problem solved soon. Many thanks

  37. I every time spent my half an hour to read this website’s content daily along with a cup of coffee.

  38. What’s up, just wanted to say, I enjoyed this blog post.
    It was helpful. Keep on posting!

  39. Hellο! Tһiѕ is my fiгst comment here sⲟ I jᥙst wanteԀ to giνe a quick shout оut
    and tell you I гeally enjoy reading through yοur blog posts.
    Ꮯan үou recommend any other blogs/websites/forums tҺat cover tɦе same
    subjects? Thank you!

  40. I constantly spent my half an hour to read this blog’s posts every day along
    with a cup of coffee.

  41. Hi there, You have done a great job. I’ll certainly digg it
    and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they’ll be benefited from this site.

  42. Good answers in return of this query with solid arguments and explaining
    everything concerning that.

Speak Your Mind