Super Bowl XLVI Predictions: New England Patriots v New York Giants – The MSF Team Chimes In

You’ve read all the previews.

You’ve soaked up all the hype.

You know Rob Gronkowski is as human as Greek legend Achilles.

The only thing you don’t know is how it’s going to end. Not a problem. Many of us at MSF have an opinion and think we know exactly how it’s going to go down.

Here are some of our experts’ predictions.

super bowl xlvi predictions - new york giants v new england patriots

Jerod Morris – MSF Founder, Managing Editor 

(San Fransisco 49ers and Miami Dolphins fan)

At this point, I trust Eli Manning more in a big game than Tom Brady. Since I think this will be a relatively close game, that splits the difference for me.

I also think that the Giants are simply a bad matchup for New England, regardless of Rob Gronkowski’s health. New York can get pressure with their front four, especially up the middle, which always seems to rattle Brady and make him more inaccurate than normal. And the weakness of the Patriots’ D – the secondary – plays right into the hands of Eli and his trio of great receivers.

As soon as I saw that this was the Super Bowl matchup, I was convinced New York would win. Nothing since then has changed my mind.

Of course, the last time these two teams played in the Super Bowl, the team that was obviously going to win did not. So what the hell does I or anyone else really know?


  • Super Bowl XLVI Prediction: Giants 24 | Patriots 17


Drew Lange – MSF Senior Writer 

(Minnesota Vikings fan)

The Giants are going to blow the Patriots out of the water. With New York’s stellar passing offense and New England’s weak passing defense, expect the Giants to top the Patriots big.

  • Super Bowl XLVI Prediction: Giants 30 | Patriots 17

Jonathan Washburn – MSF Senior Writer

(Indianapolis Colts)

I like the Giants 31 – 17. Because I hate Tom Brady and he hasn’t won a ring since the Pats stopped cheating. I don’t care if that is completely devoid of logic.

Keith Mullet – MSF Senior Writer

(Oakland Raiders)

I know the Giants are hot and Eli is playing out of his mind, but there is no way Belichick and Brady let Coughlin and Eli beat them again.

Everyone talks about how bad New England’s pass defense is, but consider that many of the yards they allowed happened while they were up big in games and playing a lax prevent and trying to burn out the clock.

I expect the Patriots to contain the fearsome front line of New York and get out to a healthy lead, only to allow the Giants to score a couple of times late to make the final look respectable.

  • Super Bowl XLVI Prediction: New England 34 | New York 27

Chris Callaway – MSF Contributor

(Green Bay Packers)

Bill Belichick won’t lose to the Giants in the Super Bowl twice.

  • Super Bowl XLVI Prediction: Patriots 38 | Giants 24

Brian Dilsheimer – MSF Contributor

(Philadelphia Eagles)

New England 27, NYG 20.  I can’t get away from revenge game angle…

Jim McGrew – MSF Contributor

(Chicago Bears)

All signs point to a New York win in convincing fashion and most of the “experts” agree.

The Giants defense is playing much better now than in the regular season. Their offense is clicking on all cylinders. New England’s defense is susceptible and the cornerbacks are a big concern. Gronkowski is not 100% with a high ankle sprain.

Which makes this the perfect upset opportunity for Belichick and Brady.

  • Super Bowl XLVI Prediction: New England Patriots 31 | New York Giants 28

Tyler Juranovich – MSF Featured Columnist

(Chicago Bears)

Giants 20 …. Jay Cutler 30

And for me…

Amanda Lawson – MSF Featured Columnist

(Green Bay Packers)

Momentum is what carried my beloved Packers through the playoffs last year, and it’s what carried the Giants when they beat the “perfect” Patriots in 2008. Once again, the Giants found the motivation to become a top contending team after their loss to Green Bay in December during the regular season.

Eli Manning will lead the Giants offense to drive over the Patriots defense for another Super Bowl victory. At least Tom Brady will still have his Uggs.

  • Super Bowl 46 Prediction: Giants 33 | Patriots 27

So there you have it. MSF writers are split right down the middle: 4 for the Giants and 4 for the Patriots (plus Tyler and his Jay Cutler prediction). What do you think?

Who do you think will win Super Bowl XLVI?

  • New England Patriots (59%, 325 Votes)
  • New York Giants (41%, 222 Votes)

Total Voters: 547

Loading ... Loading ...

Enjoy your Super Bowl Sunday!

About Amanda Lawson

A Wisconsinite stuck in Iowa, Amanda began her journey as a new baseball and Twins fan by sharing her experience on Midwest Sports Fans with the Beginning Baseball column. You can follow her on Twitter @AmandaRLawson to stay up-to-date on the Green Bay Packers, Wisconsin Badgers, and other sports information. Besides her work on MSF, Amanda also contributes her Packer knowledge at PocketDoppler and co-hosts every Thursday night on CheeseheadRadio.


  1. I used to be suggested this web site by way of my cousin. I’m not certain whether or not this publish is written by way of him as no one else know such detailed about my trouble. You are amazing! Thank you!

Speak Your Mind