Mark Buerhle’s hunting hypocrisy

Editor’s Note: This article was written by Andrew Schwartz, a native of Washington D.C., and former college baseball player at the University of Rochester, who now resides in New Orleans. (Article edited by AJ Kaufman)

In 2005, Mark Buehrle helped me win my fantasy baseball league by going 16-8 with a 3.12 ERA in what was a career-defining season. That was the first time I actually took notice of him—on the basis of his statistical performance.

The next time Buehrle popped up in my field of vision was in February 2009 when the Chicago Tribune reported that Buehrle was considering an early retirement. Apparently Buerhle missed his wife and 18 month-old son so much that he began giving serious consideration to hanging up his cleats in the prime of his career.

Mark Buehrle

After reading that, my perspective of Buerhle changed. I didn’t only respect him as a player; I respected him as a man. In fact, in February 2009, Buerhle represented the very antithesis of today’s typical professional athlete: a successful player who stays out of the media spotlight, and is a devoted family man. He was a man of a different era; a player who invoked memories of players like Jim Rice and Cal Ripken—men who defined their legacies by what they did off the field as much as by what they did on it.

But now, two years after that humbling and touching story, Buehrle has redefined his legacy…by destroying it.

In a recent article on MLB.com, Buehrle admitted that he and his wife would watch Philadelphia Eagles games, hoping that Michael Vick would “get hurt,” and that believed that “something bad needs to happen” to Vick. It wasn’t Tucker Carlson from last December, but close.

Despite his own love of killing animals ‘for sport,’ Buehrle claims to be an avid “animal rights activist,” so his comments need to be read in context; however, the sheer ignorance and hypocrisy belying these comments are way too much to overcome. Consequently, I will now provide ashort,  three-pronged rebuttal of Buerhle’s statements about Vick:

1) Vick has paid his debt to society.

In a recent interview, Buehrle defended his “hunting” of animals on the fact that the act of hunting is legal. Therefore, it’s safe to assume that Buehrle stands behind our nation’s legal system—the same legal system which has conclusively decided that Michael Vick has paid his debt to society.

Buehrle’s actions of apparently disagreeing with the determinations of our legal system, while concurrently using it as a shield to defend his own actions, seems hypocritical.

2) The “Culture” Defense.

After Buehrle’s initial comments about Vick surfaced, it was revealed that Buerhle enjoys hunting deer, ducks, and bears. When Buehrle was subsequently asked how he could have such animosity for Vick, when he himself kills animals, he responded with a cultural defense:

“Hunting is a sport…If that’s illegal, shame on my dad and my grandpa and his grandpa. It’s kind of been brought up throughout the history of America.”

In other words, Buehrle was brought up in a culture where hunting wasn’t only commonplace, it was part of everyday life.

There is a particularly interesting analogy to Buehrle’s comments regarding his lifelong experiences with hunting and Vick’s recent comments to the Los Angeles Times regarding his own lifelong experiences with dog-fighting:

Vick, who attended his first dog-fight as a 7-year old, reflected that “dog fighting was a part of [the] black culture” of his youth. Vick’s brother, Marcus, reiterated this notion by stating that when he and Vick grew up “[they] never knew there was nothing wrong with it.”

 3) Vick’s Contribution to the Cause

In addition to paying his debt to society (and we know many athletes have done worse and received far lesser punishments) and losing all of his money, Vick’s contributed money to fighting animal cruelty, regularly volunteers his time, and continuously gives public speeches to students and others about making good choices, and being kind to animals.

Buerhle has purportedly ended this discussion as of last night, but I anticipate the backlash will carry over for days and possibly weeks. And for what its worth, I cannot find anything on-line showing Mark Buehrle’s support of “dog rights” beyond empty rhetoric (i.e. no actions, just words). Consequently, I feel safe making the argument that Michael Vick has actually done more for “dog rights” than Mark Buerhle ever has or ever will.
 
Go figure.

 

E-mail the author: drewcando1@gmail.com



About AJ Kaufman

A former schoolteacher and military historian, A.J. now works in public relations. As an MSF columnist since 2009, he supports anything baseball-related. Raised in San Diego, A.J. has since resided in numerous parts of America, including Colorado, Florida, Indiana, Maryland, Minnesota, Nebraska, New York, Ohio and Washington State. After departing the coasts in 2005, he's traveled the back roads of all 50 states and prefers the Heartland. Married to Maria, A.J. is the author of three books and enjoys reading presidential biographies.

Comments

  1. Killing animals for fun is killing animals for fun.

  2. Correct. But the psycho Vick haters don't care about something as straightforward as that comment.

  3. Alto lá!!! Foda-se POC, PES é jogo para homens e vai continuar a ser. E não me venhas com a conversa da treta do FIFA, porque isso é para losers, que não têm mãhiznoas para o PES. :)Agora mais a sério, vens ou não connosco ao Vale?

  4. Well done article that. I’ll make sure to use it wisely.

  5. This is another one of your posts i’ve looked at every day since you made it- I just love these photos and am very jealous of you for living somewhere so special.

  6. Hi Vicki,Dave Birkenmeier the GM of schnucks on claytonand Lindbergh rd. recommeded us to Ally Favrefor a food and wine event. I played phone tag with Ally. I would love to be included. Im looking for more details. Please give me a call.Dan Badock314-241-7956 Soulards314-972-2339 cellthank you, Dan

  7. The Community Reinvestment Act was passed in 1977. Subprime lending didn’t begin in earnest until 2001.Lies.The subsequent amendments to the act had subprime lendiing a major problem well before 2001.Bush did not help avert the problem, but there were many hands involved.Obama’s ties to Madeline Talbott and ACORN are a good place to start.Try googling it and ignore Gordon’s blather.

  8. remarque concernant Onctose : il existe deux types l’un avec et l’autre sans cortisone. j’opte pour « sans cortisone » surtout pour les enfants.Et d’accord avec Laura, l’aspivenin c’est bien !

  9. I was so confused about what to buy, but this makes it understandable.

  10. I agree with you Sai. "Person interested" is equal to an “interested party/necessary party". This becomes apparent by paying heed to the choice of words used in 25 (1). The legislative intent by using the words "any person" clearly distinguishes the "locus standi" of the person as compared to "person interested" in section 25 (2).

  11. J’ai envie d’essayer toutes tes recettes et quand je me decide pour l’une d’entre elles j’en vois une autre qui me tente aussi (mais mes hanches risquent de ne pas apprécier un trop grand nombre de test !)Ce cake a l’air assez simple et je l’ai vu sur d’autres blogs donc j’imagine qu’il doit être très bon mais si tu as une recette de cake au chocolat ou de fondant que tu préfères je serais très interresséeJe trouve le look de ton blog vraiment super et tes photos très réussies

  12. Mä käytän Dr Hauschkan puhdistusemulsiota ja -kasvovettä ja kesäaikaan en tarvitse kosteusvoidetta ollenkaan, sillä nuo tuotteet on itsessään suht kosteuttavat. Talvella käytän lisäksi Dr Hauschkan ruusuvoidetta.

  13. Hi Neil and Helen,I follow your adventures every so often and can hardly believe all the experiences you’re having. You seem to be encountering all shades of human nature, good and bad. I wish you both safe travel and good health in 2011 and look forward to reading more of your escapades,Daniel

  14. Продам очередь в СПб на Polo седан (тёмно серый) цена авто 429т.рВнесён залог 10т.р + 15 хочу за очередь (возможен торг)8 905 288 44 00 Иван

  15. Quer-me parecer que encontro matéria suficiente para processar judicialmente o caro Dr. Tavares Moreira.Uma queixazinha para o tribunal europeu dos direitos humanos, por discriminação.Com que então, ao pobre Bartolomeu, cabe únicamente o direito a um café e uma bebida… espirituosa(!?)Sempre queria ver se no meio desta balburdia toda, não persistisse em alguns o espirituosismo…;)))

  16. Economies are in dire straits, but I can count on this!

  17. Am dat like cu numele Ivascu Laura.Ultima carte citita a fost Zece Negri Mititei de Agatha Christie. O carte plina de mister care odata inceputa, trebuie citita pagina cu pagina pana la sfarsit pentru a afla deznodamantul total neasteptat. Mi-a placut aceasta carte pentru ca a fost una dintre putinele carti pe care nu le-am putut lasa din mana pana nu le-am terminat.

  18.   Espen: Beklager at jeg kommer nÃ¥ og ødelegger hele den positive atmosfæren deres her inne, men dere har tydeligvis, helt klart ikke, løpt noen høstturer pÃ¥ Jæren. For her er det definitivt IKKE en fin tid vi gÃ¥r i møte ;pDa løper du heller A til B turer. Løper du medvind hele veien og tar bussen hjem =)

  19. Bruno Gonçalves 21/11/2008 ResponderEu também só vi hoje pela manhã. Até estranhei num primeiro momento, mas depois achei a sacada muito legal, afinal de contas a carinha do Gmail, apesar de muito funcional, era meio sem graça.Espero que os temas possam ser editáveis e que possamos também criar os nossos. Ai sim vai ficar muito bom!

  20. Nice weblog here! Also your website loads up very fast! What host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link on your host? I want my website loaded up as quickly as yours lol

  21. nossa, é complicado viu… esses pseudocéticos insistem em querer ser os possuidores da verdade. Mesmo com a definição clara de que ceticismo é a doutrina segundo a qual o espírito humano não pode atingir NENHUMA certeza a respeito da verdade, vocês ainda insistem em falar baboseiras.ALIÁS, O QUE DEFINE O ESPÍRITO CIENTÍFICO NIHIL?SÓ PODE SER BRINCADEIRA, NÉ?

Trackbacks

  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by billyhayes, Devon Alexandre. Devon Alexandre said: Mark Buerhle’s hunting hypocrisy: Editor’s Note: This article was written by Andrew Schwartz, a native of Washi… http://bit.ly/i83Hp3 […]

Speak Your Mind