Inspiring Story of Tom Walter and Kevin Jordan Inspires the Greatest Reader Comment…Maybe Ever

The screenshot below is from this story at that briefly touches on the most poignantly awesome sports story of the new year.

In short: Tom Walter, a head coach of the Wake Forest baseball team, donated a kidney to Kevin Jordan, a freshman outfielder. That kind of selflessness and sacrifice is exactly what coaches try to instill in their players and teams; Tom Walter actually led by incredible example. It’s a great story. (For more on it, click here.)

What caught my eye about the post at The Chronicle was the first comment on the story. Take a look:


Screenshot source: The Chronicle

What makes this comment – Does this violate NCAA requirements regarding gifts to student athletes? – so great is that I have no idea if the commenter was being irreverent and snarky or dead serious. Either way, it’s a perfectly appropriate comment to make. Such is the ambiguity the NCAA has wrought with its over-complicated and contradictory rule book and methods and enforcement.

I have to assume that such an act – donating an organ to a player – is not against NCAA rules. How could it be, right? It’s not something that happens often and the human interest benefits are so profound that the NCAA could not possibly penalize someone for doing so…right?

I am sitting right now thinking about this, and I don’t know for certain. I really don’t. I assume it’s not against any rule, I hope it’s not against rule, but I would put nothing past the NCAA when it comes to absurdity. There really is a part of me that thinks it very well could violate some arcane, obscure NCAA rule, and I bet you’re now starting to question it yourself. (Are you?)

nick-sabanBecause here’s the thing: as I ruminate on this, all I keep thinking about is that somewhere Nick Saban, after reading the story of Tom Walter and Kevin Jordan, is trying to find out if Jadeveon Clowney has a relative in need of a kidney. Gene Chizik probably is too. If it meant signing the #1 player in the country, don’t you think Saban, Chizik, and other coaches of their win-at-all-costs ilk would donate a kidney?

Okay, maybe not…but maybe.

Admit that you at least considered it as a possibility. And if that’s the case, wouldn’t the NCAA have to step in and make some kind of rule so the unscrupulous Sabans and Chiziks and Caliparis of the world don’t start donating organs – or finding donors – as yet another way of luring recruits?

And would it even be so bad if they did? Who cares what their motives are…if they donate a kidney, isn’t ultimately a wonderfully good thing to do? So what if it’s part of a grander plan to lure a recruit a campus?

Update: I decided to take a poll on this to see just how ridiculous you think the notion is:

Do you think Nick Saban would donate a kidney if it meant signing a top recruit?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

It’s ridiculous, this discussion is. All of it. Totally ridiculous. I feel ridiculous even typing what I just typed. And yet…I can’t help but feel that maybe it’s only a touch ridiculous, and that we really are not that far away from something like this in the current environment of college sports. Then I think that’s what is truly ridiculous, before demanding to myself that I stop thinking about all this ridiculousness right now.

And I got all of this from from one reader comment that asked a perfectly logical (or snarky) question in response to a beautiful, inspiring story. Am I the only one?


* – Nick Saban photo credit: KEVIN C. COX / GETTY IMAGES via Seattle Times

About Jerod Morris

I love words. I write for Copyblogger and founded MSF, The Assembly Call, & Primility. I practice yoga, eat well, & strive for balance. I love life. Namaste. Say hi on Twitter, Facebook, & G+.


  1. CoastGhost says:

    Funny stuff. But … You surfed over a couple of known cheaters to hang your punchline on a coach with a perfectly clean record. Why is that? You had half a dozen people who are guilty or surrounded by thick black smoke in order to attack a clean program. I think you should be forced to defend that in an intellectually honest world. But of course, this is America and we have "freedom of speech" here … which evidently means you can say anything you want to say to serve your agenda without repercussions. Other than that, nice column.

    • I'll tell you why: I do not like Nick Saban. (Full disclosure: I am a Miami Dolphins fan…so this has a lot to do with it). Not one bit. And the joke is stronger and more relatable to a greater number of people when it has Saban's name attached to it, but because many other people do not like him. Plus, here's the thing: it's not exactly a rip job on Saban. Obviously he has a "clean" record in terms of not having any major NCAA violations, but he most certainly will stretch every rule to the absolute limit (as he should) and will stop at nothing to win (as he should). If there is a coach out there who would actually do something as crazy as donate a kidney to get a player, I think Saban would be the guy (again, with the assumption that a) this is legal by NCAA rules and b) that it would actually work – it's a pretty unlikely hypothetical). So while I am using Saban's reputation against him here, I don't think it's entirely negative. It's just that he, more than anyone else, will do ANYTHING to win. Everyone can judge that for themselves. In many ways I respect that about him to be honest. But it doesn't mean he's not purely evil. ;-)

  2. CoastGhost says:

    Of course, reconsidering my compliment, Al Gore could have written a funny column based on that user comment.

  3. hey check dis out

  4. any reason your picking on coaches from the state of alabama?

  5. Great post. Really Great.

  6. Very good post.Thanks Again. Keep writing.

  7. wow, awesome post.Really thank you! Great.

  8. Really enjoyed this article post.Really thank you! Cool.

  9. Very neat article.Much thanks again. Great.

  10. I really enjoy the post.Really thank you! Cool.

  11. Thanks so much for the blog article.Thanks Again. Awesome.

  12. Im grateful for the post.Much thanks again. Want more.

  13. Really appreciate you sharing this article post.Really thank you! Great.

  14. RUrvf4 Lea margot horoscope tarot de marseille gratuit divinatoire

  15. “Thanks for the diverse tips discussed on this site. I have observed that many insurers offer customers generous discount rates if they decide to insure multiple cars with them. A significant amount of households have got several motor vehicles these days, particularly people with elderly teenage children still located at home, as well as the savings on policies might soon increase. So it pays off to look for a bargain.”


  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Jerod Morris, Jerod Morris, Izzy Gould, tracy roberts, Alec McNees and others. Alec McNees said: RT @JerodMSF: We think alike RT @sportspickle: NCAA Suspends Player Who Received Free Kidney From His Coach — http: … […]

  2. […] DE Jadeveon Clowney Updates: He is no longer considering Bama Story of Tom Walter Donating Kidney to Kevin Jordan Inspires Best Reader Comment…Maybe Ever I'll assume this hasn't been posted under this thread. If so, sorry. But it was a blend of heart […]

Speak Your Mind