Photo Gallery: Who is the More Desirable ‘Girl Next Door’ – Rachel McAdams or Anne Hathaway?

Last night at dinner, my girlfriend and I got into a debate about Anne Hathaway. She loves her while I’m not a big fan.

For some reason, whenever I think about Anne Hathaway the only images my mind conjures up are: a) that annoying Princess Diaries movie (never saw it, but the ads annoyed me) and b) her role in Bride Wars – and let’s be honest, there are few things less attractive or desirable than a Bridezilla.

Despite our differences on Hathaway, my girlfriend and I do agree on Rachel McAdams. I’ve always been a big fan ever since I was duped into watching The Notebook, and then she earned my respect and admiration with her role in Wedding Crashers.

Since these two young women both have movies coming out soon – McAdams stars opposite Harrison Ford in Morning Glory and Hathaway stars opposite Jake Gyllenhal in Love and Other Drugs – I figured the time was right to take a brief foray outside of sports and celebrate the fairer sex. While I have my opinion on which of these “girls next door” I like better, I’m curious to see how many of you agree.

So, just as we did with Julie Bown and Sofia Vergara from Modern Family, let’s let the pictures do the talking and decide which girl next door is more desirable: Rachel McAdams or Anne Hathaway.

rachel-mcadams-anne-hathaway-pics-photos

The more desirable "girl next door" is...

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Since I can’t vote for my girlfriend, McAdams gets my vote. Until Hathaway does a kickass movie like Wedding Crashers to wipe the Princess Diaries and Bride Wars from my memory, she just can’t compete.

And in case you like to do some side-by-side comparing before you vote, the pictures below are there for your perusal and enjoyment.

rachel-mcadams-pics-cute

anne-hathaway-pics-hot

rachel-mcadams-pics

anne-hathaway-pics-close-up

rachel-mcadams-pics-sexy-2

anne-hathaway-pics-lingerie

rachel-mcadams-pics-tie

anne-hathaway-pics-hotel

rachel-mcadams-pics-smile

anne-hathaway-pics-hair-back

rachel-mcadams-pics-shirt

anne-hathaway-pics-get-smart

rachel-mcadams-pics-short-hair

anne-hathaway-pics-natural

rachel-mcadams-pics-blonde

anne-hathaway-pics-cleavage

rachel-mcadams-pics-smile

anne-hathaway-pics-orange

rachel-mcadams-pics-sexy

anne-hathaway-pics-sexy

rachel-mcadams-pics-pink-hair

anne-hathaway-vogue-pics

rachel-mcadams-pics-close-up

anne-hathaway-pics-aqua

rachel-mcadams-pics-cute

And now, to wrap things up, I’ve chosen two images completely at random.

I swear…they were chosen at random.

I’m not trying to influence the vote with my own personal opinion.

Serious. I promise.

Rachel-McAdams-animated-GIF-sexy

anne-hathaway-princess-diaries

I mean, how would either of these pictures influence the vote anyway. Right?

Sharing This Article Supports Operation Homefront -- Here's How




About Jerod Morris

A proud graduate of Indiana University, Jerod Morris founded Midwest Sports Fans in August of 2008 and has been its Managing Editor every day since. Follow him on Twitter (@JerodMorris) for MSF updates, sports discussion, and a compelling daily assortment of funny and interesting links.
In addition to his work at MSF, Jerod hosts the fast-growing Indiana basketball postgame show The Assembly Call and provides regular music recommendations at IndieChristmas.com. He also helped develop the Synthesis Managed WordPress Hosting platform on which MSF and all of his other sites are run.

  • http://www.nonpopulist.com Nonpopulist

    gotta be McAdams

  • http://www.midwestsportsfans.com JerodMSF

    I have to agree.

  • Maki Lane

    I love Anne Hathaway so much! Devil Wears Prada!! I guess I equally love Rachel, but only as Regina George in Mean Girls. Guess I'm voting for different reasons though, lol

  • http://www.midwestsportsfans.com JerodMSF

    Hey, all votes count the same!

  • kristen

    mcadams all the way

  • Pingback: Daybreak Doppler: The Other Clay in Wisconsin | PocketDoppler.com

  • whiteknight

    I think Hathaway might be a little bit more attractive to me, but if I were dating one, you know McAdams would definitely be more fun, so she got my vote.

  • http://www.realfakesports.com RFS

    McAdams. Not even close

  • Sam

    Anne Hathaway for sure

  • Francesco

    Rachel McAdams has yet to show her tits. Therefore, Hathaway gets my vote.

  • guest
  • FunkInPalm Harbor

    McAdams by far, look at the a$$ in the video, goodness gracious, There is a God.

  • Derp

    McAdams has a man-jaw

  • Jaimee

    McAdams, hands down

  • tayk

    hathaway all day

  • DankStar420

    Hathaway had bigger tits, but I'd gladly stick my dick in both. pile one on top of the other, first the Hathaway pink, then the McAdams stink. While they make out. Hell yes. I could die a happy man

  • Chamrstep

    McAdams has that cute innocent face while Hathaway is more on the sultry sexy side. so I guess is depends on mood.

  • pzr

    all for H.

  • rrtyt

    The problem I see is that McAdams just plain looks like a bitch (maybe I'm just jaded from Mean Girls though) so I can never be attracted to her.

  • Kevin

    I have to say that Anne Hathaway isn't really the "girl next door" type, and she totally made an effort to escape the Princess Diaries niche as early as possible in her career- she took off her top within her first 10 minutes on screen in both Havoc and Brokeback Mountain. And seriously, after seeing her play a seriously fucked up recovering drug addict in Rachel Getting Married, I don't think I could ever believe Anne as innocent ever again. For those reasons alone, I voted for Rachel McAdams.

    But I respect Anne more as an actress.

  • Apple

    Anne Hathaway is so much classier than Rachel McAdams though. Just look at all those pictures. Anne looks so sultry; Rachel just looks like a ho.

  • bienschn

    the problem of this gallery is that they've chosen the worst pictures of mcadams and the best ones of anne so that's why it seems that anne is more pretty and classy and stuff which is not true because rachel is truely beautiful and a much better actress than anne without a doubt.
    just watch her in the movie "the notebook", she has incredible talent.

  • http://www.midwestsportsfans.com JerodMSF

    I disagree! I am the one who chose these pictures, and I think I picked some great ones of McAdams! Plus, she is who I voted for. And if the last gif and picture don't show that I think more highly of McAdams, I don't know what does.

    However, if you have better pics of McAdams, do feel free to post links. I think we'd all appreciate it…