Heartbreak for Colts: The Good, Bad & Ugly

Another snowstorm is set to hit Indianapolis tomorrow, and city officials had been concerned it might affect the putative Super Bowl celebratory parade through downtown; this is no longer an issue.

The parade will instead be in New Orleans, even as their city had actually planned one win or lose.

Last night’s game in Miami Gardens was a grave disappointment for the Circle City, and a shocking end to a season that saw central Indiana’s team, a la New England in 2007, go undefeated (in games they actually tried to win), yet fail on the world’s biggest football stage.

There was the good, the bad and the ugly from this game.

The ugly, of course, is the ultimate loss and a season many will see (and should see) as a failure.

It was good to see Peyton Manning throw for 333 yards, but he made some bad mistakes, more akin to 1998-2005 Peyton than the 2006-2010 four-time MVP versions.

Joseph Addai had his best game in three years; Reggie Wayne, playing banged up, had his worst.

The Colts outgained the Saints by 100 yards, held the league’s best offense to a very mediocre 332 yards (well below their season average, and just 51 on the ground, including a goal-line stand, despite having two injured starters), yet gave up long drives when it mattered, and did not make any big plays, while the Saints made at least one.

No one here or anywhere realized Adam Vinatieri was out this entire this season until Matt Stover missed a long field goal (one he shouldn’t have even been attempting) that changed the momentum of the game as much as New Orleans’ unorthodox onside kick to open the second half.

Jim Caldwell “managed” this talented team well all year (save for the Dec 27 Jets game), then made poor decisions:  Stover’s field goal attempt; three runs inside your own 20 late in the first half (after calling a time out to set up a drive!) that led to New Orleans’ second field goal; not getting the ball out of bounds to stop the clock on Indy’s late drives.

This Colts team is young enough, especially where it counts, to be solid next season; but 71 year-old Tom Moore, the only offensive coordinator Peyton Manning knows at the pro level, is retiring.

As I drove into work this morning, people didn’t seem depressed like the past two winters when the Colts lost to San Diego. Then, a long, cold off-season awaited, as those games ended Indy’s season about a month earlier than this year, without a single playoff win, and to a team that is cocky and unlikable. New Orleans, overall, is likable, even if the media (Katie Couric, Spike Lee, et al) really got unnecessarily annoying with their “the world is cheering for this city due to Katrina perpetual hype…” the past fortnight, as if the Colts are an evil empire akin to New England.

And regarding New England, there were some similarities between the Colts’ loss and the Pats’ loss two years ago. But Colts’ fans last night were solemn, even gracious, as losing to New Orleans didn’t seem to bother them as much. This was shown on local TV, in blogs, commentaries, and on talk radio this morning. No excuses. I doubt New England fans felt similarly after their loss to New York in Arizona.

OK, it’s over. Seasons change.

Now we move down a (shorter) road to the Final Four and baseball season…

{BTW, the super bowl ads, save for a few, were as juvenile and terrible as ever.}

Share This Article:


Email Article Email Article



About AJ Kaufman

AJ Kaufman is the co-editor of Midwest Sports Fans, where he has been a columnist since March 2009. AJ, a former Los Angeles schoolteacher and Indiana military historian, is now a corporate journalist, compiling publications for organizations across the country. He is a supporter of anything baseball-related -- especially minor league ball -- and mid-major college hoops. The author of three books, AJ is married to Maria and currently lives in Lincoln, Neb.

Follow him on Twitter (@ajkauf7) for ruminations on sports, politics, history and travel.

  • tim

    Great piece

  • Ryan

    Saints played win. Colts played not to lose until it was too late. Caldwell should’ve been willing to let Peyton throw a quick slant at the end of the 2nd quarter – chances are he would’ve found someone for 10 years and a first.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/JerodMSF JerodMSF

    I agree. Nicely sums up how most Colts fans probably feel this morning.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/JerodMSF JerodMSF

    Yeah, there are lots of things to question about how Caldwell handled last night. The Saints just seemed to be in a more productive place emotionally, which falls on the head coach in many respects.

  • icecold

    Even in defeat, you tried to backhandedly make the Colts out to be the better team that should have won. More or less, your article reads as "the colts played like crap, and had they not, they would have cruised to victory." Maybe you should be giving the Saints more credit for making the Colts play like crap. Maybe Caldwell coached fine, but Peyton coached a lot better. Maybe this and maybe that, but DEFINITELY, the Saints are the better team. They showed that last night. If these teams played each other 10 times, they Saints would win more times than not. Sometimes you need to stop being a Colts fan and start being a football fan. The Saints are the superior team, bottom line…

  • Quinty

    Nice piece…I think the Colts will be a fine team next year, even with Moore retiring..Manning is like a coach on the field…

  • AJ Kaufman

    I'm a Denver fan. I just live in Indy. No bias here.

    I think the teams split ten games. This was basically a home game for N.O. and Indy had injuries. Colts also were uninspired having won three years ago and having their owner/coach/GM steal their peffect season on 27 Dec.

    The only bias here comes from your anonymous comment — as a Saints fan/supporter. Statistically, the Colts dominated. The Saints made one huge play and a gutsy call worked out.

  • Marv

    I agree with the comments. The Colts were out coached. Sean Payton did an incredible job. Hopefully, Coach Caldwell was paying attention.

  • widdle

    I am disappoined about the loss but I am happy for Brees and the Saints too. They really did play a good game and deserved the title. No excuses for the Colts! Still love'em but they did not play to win.

  • beau

    Great game by the Saints…they played to win. However, if you really know your football you would be an idiot to think the Saints would come out on top if this game was played ten times more than two times. Colts did not play well and made some bad decisions(both coaching and player). The Colts are truly the class of the NFL and when firing on all cylinders just can't be beat. This was truly a great win for the Saints and a surprising one. New Orleans has reason to be proud of their team on and off the field and proud of a great quarterback and man such as Drew Brees. He's a credit to football, a winner, and a role model to every young person (and to some of us older ones). best of luck next year….the Colts and Saints could very well be back….

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/JerodMSF JerodMSF

    I'd like to get your reaction to the fact that only 11 Colts fan showed up at the airport to welcome the team home. I have to be honest with you…I think that absolutely sucks. I've been saying for awhile now that Colts fans have an unruly sense of entitlement and don't appreciate what Polian and Manning have given them. Maybe it takes the perspective of a Browns fan to see it. But for only 11 fans to greet a team that gave them a 16-3 record and had a chance in the 4th Q to win the Super Bowl? That is terrible. The team deserved a lot better.

  • AJ Kaufman

    Yes, I'd agree Colts would win 7 of 10 on neutral field. One game is one game, but that's how the NFL is. It's why, unlike baseball and hoops, the best team does not always win the title. The Colts are/were a better team, but like the Giants two years ago vs NE (and many other times), the better team lost.

  • AJ Kaufman

    How many normally show up in a blizzard to welcome a team that lost the super bowl back to town? People have lives and jobs. Was Bill Polian there to help shovel the streets or cheer a school custodian when he returned to work Monday after dedicating his time, 1/4th of his salary to Colts tickets and gear the past 6 months?

    How many were in Boston in 2008 or Phoenix last year?

    I have no idea, and would love to know. I don't think the fans are very happy with the way the ownership and coaching staff treated the fans this season. I don't blame them either.

    I don't think there is a sense of entitlement as the team was awful for a decade. They appreciate Peyton and the success. They don't need to drive to the airport in the depths of winter to prove that. They spoke with their wallets all year.

  • AJ Kaufman

    http://espn.go.com/nfl/attendance

    As you can see, each year, they're 95% capacity, while most are 95-100% or higher (ala Colts)

  • AJ Cough

    I agree with icecold–the Saints looked like the superior team, not just on "one huge play" but really for the entire game. The gutsy call wasn't all that gutsy, it was calculated. Peyton saw something in how the Colts lineup for kickoffs and exploited a weakness. Statistically, the Colts hardly dominated. The Saints constantly worked with a shorter field. Defensively, the Saints were more dominant, causing playmaking turnovers. That has been their calling card all season. The injury argument is comical. It's the NFL–all teams have injuries. The Saints NOT having an injury was the deviation from the norm. And your "Colts were uninspired" comment is equally laughable. If a coach can't motivate a team to get inspired for a superbowl, then maybe that says something about him. And as for their super bowl three years ago, half the team is different so it's a moot argument…

  • AJ Kaufman

    Thanks for mocking my name and failing to use yours. It makes your otherwise semi-coherent comment uninteresting & non-credible.

  • AJ Kaufman

    Here is a summary of why the Colts, despite truly being a better team, lost (which happens in a one game scenario):

    http://www.indystar.com/article/20100209/SPORTS15…

    "It felt like an extension of the way both teams approached the final weeks of the regular season, the way the Saints looked at perfection and said, "Let's go for it," and the Colts said, "Um, we have other goals, thank you very much, and if you don't like it, too bad.

    "When the big moments came Sunday, the Saints were willing to walk way out there on the tightrope with no safety net. They dared to be great. And even after a fourth-and-goal at the Colts 1 got stuffed, they still got their field goal, still got to go into the locker room with all the momentum.

    "Greatness requires the courage to take great risks. The Saints were willing to take them. The Colts were not. And after a virtually perfect season from Jim Caldwell and the Colts coaching staff, I thought Sean Payton and his people absolutely outcoached, outschemed and out-thought the Indianapolis contingent."