Week 5 NFL Power Rankings
This week, we have our first ever tie in the Power Rankings. I had a real tough decision choosing who would be first and who would be second so there is a tie for first place.
T-1. New York Giants (Last 6 [+5])
Ok, so Archie Manning must be sitting at home smiling at both of his boys who will tie for 1st in Big MB’s Power Rankings for Week 5.
Obviously, the Giants don’t miss Plaxico Burress one bit. The G-men’s destruction of Kansas City only showcased Manning and his receivers. Smith and Manningham continue to impress and Brandon Jacobs is the beast of the NFC East. Next week is a HUGE NFC power game as the Saints come to town.
[Editor's Note: it's Big MB writing this column...any guess who the other 4-0 team is that he has tied for first? It shouldn't take more than one...]
T-1. Indianapolis Colts (Last 3 [+2])
Can Peyton get any better?
Manning has had 4 straight games of 300+ yards for the first time in his career. Joseph Addai and Donald Brown are starting to look like an unstoppable backfield tandem, both rushing for a touchdown a piece in Indy’s dismantling of Seattle. And worst of all for other teams in the NFL, this defense under Larry Coyer is looking like somewhat of an immovable object.
Until the slop minutes of the matchup with Seattle when Indy had their 3rd string in, the Colts held Seattle to only 3 points, after holding an explosive Arizona offense to only 10. Next Week presents an interesting match up against 0-4 Tennessee.
3. New Orleans Saints (Last 2 [-1])
For the second straight week, Drew Brees didn’t throw one touchdown, but the Saints continue to roll as they took down the heavily favored Jets of New York. The defense had two touchdowns, and Pierre Thomas put one in on the ground. This team seams to be able to win games just about any way they want. Next week is a huge match up as they travel to New York to battle it out with the also undefeated Giants.
4. Minnesota Vikings (Last 5 [+1])
Brett Favre came out in a fury and never looked back in this game. The Vikings defense looked as good as ever putting Aaron Rodgers on his back very often, and more importantly have established that teams can no longer put 8 or 9 in the box against Peterson. Favre is really clicking with this team now, which is very scary for all of those in the NFC North.
5. Denver Broncos (Last 10 [+5])
O.K., I can admit when I am wrong. I was dead wrong. This Denver team may be more of a contender than I had previously thought. Although they looked stale early at home against Dallas, a late touchdown catch by Brandon Marshall, highlighted by a great run after the catch and horrible tackling by Dallas, then a redzone stand by the defense and Denver is now 4-0. Interesting.
6. New England Patriots (Last 12 [+6])
Don’t look now, but here come the Patriots. Another scary moment for Pat fans when Brady went to the locker room, but he came back to lead his team to a victory against a very tough Baltimore team. As much as I hate giving the Pats credit, they are playing better, and now have beaten two very tough teams, and are in a two-way tie in the AFC East with the Jets.
7. Baltimore Ravens (Last 1 [-6])
After a disappointing loss to New England, Baltimore takes a significant drop in my Power Rankings, but not necessarily because of their play, but more because of the play of the teams that moved ahead of them. Baltimore is still one of the best teams in the league, but now find themselves in a two-way tie for the lead in the AFC North with surprise Cinderella Cincinnati.
8. San Fransico 49ers (Last 13 [+5])
Along with Cincy, the 49ers seem to be putting together a Cinderella season after their 35-0 dismantling of St. Louis, who seems to be just awful. No Frank Gore? No problem. Shaun Hill seems to be making a name for himself as a legitimate QB in this league. Now, if only they could get this whole Crabtree thing under wraps, this team could possible be very dangerous.
9. Atlanta Falcons (Last 7 [-2])
Not much to report here, Atlanta was on a bye week after a tough loss to New England, so they take a little hit on their rankings, just due to inactivity, but at least they didn’t completely fall off like the Eagles.
10. Cincinnati Bengals (Last 11 [+1])
The Bengals still remain somewhat of an NFL Cinderella, now 3-1 and tied with the Ravens for first in the AFC North, perhaps football’s most brutal division. They did struggle against a weak Browns team, but a win is a win. Chad Ochocinco and Carson Palmer seem to have put aside their differences, Ochocinco had 2 TD’s in this game.
11. New York Jets (Last 4 [-7])
Remember last week when I told you that I was hesitant to put the Jets very high in my rankings, due to the fact that they were led by a rookie QB? Well, Sunday’s loss to the nothing-less-than-impressive Saints proved that Sanchez may not quite be ready to be the NFL MVP. Yes, he is an impressive rookie QB, but he will make mistakes, just as he did this week. Don’t sell your stock of this team just yet though, they are definitely still a contender.
12. Chicago Bears (Last 8 [-4])
It looked a little scary for the Bears early against the hungry Lions (cheesy I know), but the second half proved to be all Chicago as Jay Cutler and Company put it to Detroit and came away victorious to establish a 3-1 record. Matt Forte seems to be waking up as well, and this defense is playing quite well without its emotional and physical leader, Brian Unlacher.
13. Houston Texans (Last Not Ranked)
Those who know me know that I am very high on the Houston Texans this year. I predicted them to make the playoffs, and even possibly challenge the vaunted Colts for the AFC South Title. I’m not quite sure they will challenge the Colts with the way that Indy is playing, but Matt Schaub is a very, very good QB, and it doesn’t hurt to be throwing passes to a beast like Andre Johnson. Oh yeah, Steve Slaton decided to show up to the party too.
Keep your eyes on the Texans, it just may be their time to shine.
14. Pittsburgh Steelers (Last 15 [+1])
The Steelers got off to a great start against the Chargers, but somehow almost tried to give the game away in the 4th quarter. They did hold on to win 38-28, but there may be concern in how they let the Chargers back in this one. The one positive the Steel City fans can take from this is Rashard Mendenhall. Pittsburgh finally found a run game with Mendenhall having over 160 yards and 2 TD’s.
15. Green Bay Packers (Last 9 [-6])
This week, the Pack made the top 15 because there really weren’t too many other choices I liked better. Minnesota exposed this poor offensive line again. If Green Bay wants to have a franchise quarterback, they had better work to protect him better. The Pack has a lot of work to do, and they will be climbing an uphill battle with Minnesota and Chicago looking so good in this division.
This Week’s Biggest Winner
New England Patriots (+6) – Just when you thought they were done….don’t look now here comes the Pats.
This Week’s Biggest Loser
New York Jets (-7) – I warned Jets fans to be aware of the Rookie. He is a good player, but he is a rookie. But don’t worry Jet fans, you still have a great team, and a good chance at the playoffs.
**********
You can follow Big MB on twitter @ www/twitter.com/mylesb3269
Be sure to check in every Tuesday for Big MB’s NFL Power Rankings, every Wednesday for “I’ll Tell You This” and every week to the MSF podcast!!!
Tags: Atlanta Falcons, Baltimore Ravens, Chicago Bears, cincinnati bengals, denver broncos, football, Green Bay Packers, houston texans, Indianapolis Colts, Minnesota Vikings, new england patriots, new orleans saints, new york giants, new york jets, NFL, nfl power rankings, nfl week 5, pittsburgh steelers, power rankings, san francisco 49ers
---------------
If you enjoyed this post, please consider sharing with your friends:
@Jerod
Ok, so call me a homer, but I personally believe that the Colts are the best team in the league. At least I put the Giants first. How bout them Browns?
Reply
JerodMSF Reply:
October 6th, 2009 at 1:09 pm
Thanks for rubbing it in…ass. Once Peyton retires and the Colts return to being a downtrodden laughingstock, I'll be sure to rub it in your face.
Reply
KVB Reply:
October 6th, 2009 at 2:27 pm
Dude Curtis Painter will take over at some point and they won't miss a beat.
Reply
JerodMSF Reply:
October 6th, 2009 at 6:12 pm
He was so close to winning the Heisman last year…
Ok, this is the 1st time I've ever read your power rankings, but you definitely have a few teams in the top 15 that I and 90% of football fans just can not agree too. The Texans at 13, come on what are you smoking (and pass it this way)… I have wanted the Texans to be a good team for a couple years now cause I do see the potential but really we have never seen them play to that potential. They lose they games they should win and win one or two against teams they shouldn't. My magic 8-ball is seeing 8-8 all the way (again). And as impressed with the Donkeys play as I am, I really did predict 1-3 at this point, the fact that you have them ranked in the Top 5 is retarded. Come on, they beat the Bungles by a miracle, then took out two helpless teams in Oakland and Cleveland. They did impress me with the win over Dallas, but in the long run I think that says more about Dallas than it does about Denver. Don't get me wrong they are playing ballz to the wallz but Top 5 is just way too much credit… Other than that this seems like a decent ranking,for the most part, well atleast passable. Thanks for putting it up anyways.
Reply
JerodMSF Reply:
October 6th, 2009 at 1:06 pm
Damd,
I'll speak on Big MB's behalf and thank you for you for your honest reply. Strong opinions are the best kind!
That said, while I disagree with some of MB's choices, I don't think you can fault him for putting Denver in the top 5. Power Rankings should be about what you've done to that point in the season, and regardless of where you think Denver will end up, this is a 4-0 team. I badmouthed them before last week, but that was a solid win over Dallas. In the end, we'll know everything we need to know about Denver after this weekend when they play New England. For now, I think they are deserving of a high spot.
Reply
Colleen Johnson Reply:
October 6th, 2009 at 5:05 pm
How could Denver not be ranked in the top 5? Doesn't matter who they've played, they've only allowed 26 points in the first four games. Plus, Giants barely beat Dallas so what does that say about Dallas and what does it say about the Giants? You are your record in this league, and although Denver's offense is suspect, their defense deserves top respect.
Reply
JerodMSF Reply:
October 6th, 2009 at 6:18 pm
I can't disagree with that.
Reply
Big MB Reply:
October 6th, 2009 at 8:11 pm
Damd,
Thanks for your reply. I appreciate you reading the rankings and I hope that you will come back week after week for nothing more than controversy!
I basically will echo Jerod's statement on the Broncos. If you read last week's rankings I called Denver a pretender and was quite harsh to them…However they impressed me very much this week on both sides of the ball.
They may not stay there for long, but I believe they belong there to this point in the season.
As far as Houston. I see alot of potential in this team, and I see a great QB a Freak at WR, and a beast of a RB waking up. The defense isn't too bad either. Give them a chance, I think they may surprise you.
Reply
Well, I can't say much about the rest of your rankings, but you'd better get your facts straight on number 3. 1) The Jets weren't heavily favored over the Saints. 3) The Saints don't play the Giants next week (Saints have a bye, Giants play Oakland at home) 3) The Giants travel to New Orleans to play in two weeks, not the other way around. The Giants almost certainly will be undefeated, so it'll be another huge game for the Saints, but the Saints might actually be favored in the game since they're at home. If they can manage to win against the Giants, they'll have beaten all 3 of the New York teams, one right after the other.
Reply
KVB Reply:
October 6th, 2009 at 12:49 pm
lol! Yeah the Saints were favored by 6 or 7. Colts fans don't know anything about football. Living in Indianapolis, I hear the moronic statements and yearly Super Bowl expectations. And the endless Patriots bashing and cheering for Brady to get injured. I guess Peyton has never been seriously injured in a game but a fan with any brains would respect the Patriots, not hinge all their arguments on cheating and would not cheer for other teams stars to fall.
Reply
JerodMSF Reply:
October 6th, 2009 at 1:01 pm
Wow…them's fighting words. Looking forward to MB's response…
Reply
Big MB Reply:
October 6th, 2009 at 8:19 pm
First of all KVB,
I have never celebrated Brady's injury. I have never hoped for any professional to become injured, and I have never hinged an argument on the Patriots with cheating. That being said:
I gave the Pats respect this week. They jumped 7 spots in my rankings. It doesn't mean I hate them any less. But I did give them credit where it is due.
Thems are fighting words, but diplomacy will prevail here. KVB, it seems the mistake you have made is stereo-typing. I'm disappointed in you. I expected more
Reply
JerodMSF Reply:
October 6th, 2009 at 1:00 pm
I'll fall on my sword for those errors. Big MB no doubt trusted his editor to catch that, and I didn't read carefully enough late last night when I pushed this through. Thanks for correcting us though, saints fan.
Reply
Big MB Reply:
October 6th, 2009 at 8:15 pm
First of all, thanks for the corrections.
1) When I said heavily favored, I was not speaking of the line, I was speaking of what all of the "experts" were saying. I should have made that more evident
2) I meant to report that the Saints next game was against the Giants, and not next week, point well taken.
3) The Saints are my second favorite team, only to the Colts. Whether the G-men are 5-0 when they play or not, there is no doubt that game may be an early determination of #1 in the NFC. It will definately be interesting.
Reply
ummm, the Saints have a BYE before the play the Giant at HOME. You said they travel to New York next week to play them. Do you really pay attention to football?
Reply
This just in from the Redundancy Department of Redundancy:
Like I said before , I already corrected that mistake in the comment section. Thanks for your reply.
Reply
Great rankings, the only thing I can't agree with is Houston. I feel as if they are
there due to favoritism. Plus, these rankings are also based on performance, not skill.
Even though you think Houston's skill level is good, doesn't mean they deserve to be
high in Power Rankings.
-Devon
Reply
how are the jags not ranked above the texans? give me a break!
Reply