Marvin Harrison Shooting Investigation Update: DA Press Conference Tuesday

Email Post Email Post

<<Marvin Harrison will not face charges in connection with the April, 2008 shooting in Philly.>>>

Marvin Harrison Shooting Investigation Update: Press Conference Scheduled for TuesdayBreaking news out of Philadelphia tonight: Philly District Attorney Lynne Abraham has scheduled a press conference for Tuesday, January 6 to update the Marvin Harrison shooting investigation.

If you need your memory jogged quickly, this post from back in October provides most of the details, including the civil suit that was filed against Marvin Harrison.

Basically, a shooting took place in Philadelphia last April and the gun used in the shooting belonged to Marvin Harrison. The Colts WR is reported to have been involved in an altercation with the victim before the shooting; and while there are eyewitnesses, part of the reason for the long delay in the case is purported to be credibility of witnesses.

According to My Fox Philadelphia:

Fox 29 News has learned that Philadelphia District Attorney Lynne Abraham will reveal the results of the investigation during a news conference.

Police have said the gun used in the shooting near Harrison’s car wash in the Brewerytown section of the city belonged to him.

The press conference is scheduled to start at 11:00 am and can viewed live at MyFoxPhilly.com.

As we mentioned yesterday in our post regarding the questions facing the Indianapolis Colts heading into 2009, both the legal and contractual status of Marvin Harrison are a couple of the most pertinent questions. We also said what most Colts fans and even many media members had been unwilling or reluctant to say:

Do not forget that there are still pending charges against Marvin Harrison for a shooting that took place in his hometown of Philadelphia in March of 2008. Colts fans always get mad when I bring this up, and many think this is a closed case simply because the DA’s office in Philly has not yet pushed forward, but make no mistake: this case is not over.

I am keeping an eye on this case, because sources close to the investigation say it could come to a head sometime during the first few months of 2009. Just as the New York Giants face uncertainty with the legal status of Plaxico Burress, the Colts face similar questions with Marvin Harrison; and in the end, these issues could actually make the Colts’ decision regarding Harrison’s cap number quite simple.

We will see what the outcome of tomorrow’s press conference is before making any claims that we predicted anything here before it happened. As far as I can tell, if the DA thinks their witnesses will hold up in a trial, they will move forward. If they don’t — and it’s a big if — then Harrison could avoid a criminal trial.

Driving home from work tonight I was listening to the Dan Patrick show and he was discussing a story broken by ESPN. He proceeded to say something to the effect of, “we don’t break the news, we spray the news.” I laughed, thinking of how apt a description that is of most sports blogs, including this one. Almost exclusively on this site, we simply take the stories reported by other sources and add whatever two cents we may have.

The Marvin Harrison story, however, is one that caught my eye because of the glaring lack of activity since the initial flurry of information when the shooting occurred. I did a little digging, and wasn’t just blowing smoke when I continued to post about the Marvin Harrison shooting investigation when many others treated it like a dead issue (or, to be fair, like an issue that just hadn’t had much more information released publicly — which it was.)

I guess if Marvin Harrison faces charges tomorrow, we can gives ourselves a meaningless pat on the back for following up. Otherwise, the extra time spent will have simply been a waste of time for all intents and purposes.

One question I do have is this: doesn’t the timing seem somewhat suspect? A shooting occurs in Philly a few months before NFL training camp is set to kick off, and one of the primary suspects, Marvin Harrison, is one of the most successful athletes to come out of Philadelphia. News completely dies down (other than the civil case, which is completely unrelated to the criminal investigation) and then less than 48 hours after Marvin Harrison and the Colts’ season ends, a press conference is announced.

I suppose is perfectly logical that it could just be a coincidence, but the timing certainly worked out pretty well for Marvin Harrison, the Colts, and the NFL.

I’m just saying…

…and withholding any further judgment until tomorrow.

(Update: ESPN.com has a more detailed story about the Marvin Harrison case, written by Sal Paolantonio. According to Paolantonio, the police have been pressing the DA to bring the case to a close; however, the DA wanted reportedly wanted to wait until Harrison’s NFL season was over. Paolantonio also reports that witnesses have been “less than cooperative”, leading to uncertainty.)



LOTD: Minnesota Twins Owner Carl Pohlad Dies

Email Post Email Post
carl-pohlad

About an hour ago, I made the following rather flippant remark in a post about Jay Mariotti’s first column at FanHouse:

Ladies and gentleman of the blogosphere, today was a very sad day in the sports world. No, nobody famous passed away and no superstars suffered horrible injuries (at least, not yet — and hopefully neither of these things happens the rest of tonight or I really will start to consider myself a jinx).

In the hour since I posted that article, word broke that Minnesota Twins owner Carl Pohlad passed away at age 93. I include the excerpt from the Mariotti column not to make light, but to hold myself accountable for making jokes about death. As usual, karma will come back to bite you every time.

In the interest of respecting the life and passing of Carl Pohlad, I am using today’s LOTD to provide links to stories about Pohlad’s life, his success as a both a banker and baseball owner, and some of the controversy that swirled around his sometimes rocky tenure as owner of the Twins.

My thoughts and sympathy go out to the Pohlad family, and to Twins fans everywhere.

Twins owner Pohlad dies at 93 – (SI.com)

Carl Pohlad – (Wikipedia)

Longtime Twins owner Carl Pohlad, 93, dies – (Minneapolis Star-Tribune)

Carl Pohlad ranked #245 on Forbes List of World’s Richest People – (Forbes.com)

Pohlad family maintains diverse business empire – (Minneapolis Business Journal)

Pohlad, Twins Not Sharing the Wealth – (NY Times)



Jay Mariotti Posts First Column at FanHouse – Lots of Hype, and Much of it Negative

Email Post Email Post
mariotti-bh-final

Jay Mariotti Posts First Column at FanHouseLadies and gentleman of the blogosphere, today was a very sad day in the sports world. No, nobody famous passed away and no superstars suffered horrible injuries (at least, not yet — and hopefully neither of these things happens the rest of tonight or I really will start to consider myself a jinx). And no, there were no new stories of performance enhancing drugs or athletes running afoul with the law.

Nope, the misery inflicted upon the sports world today was actually worse than what the hypothetical sum of all of the aforementioned catastrophes combined. And you probably already know what I am talking: Jay Mariotti posted his first column at FanHouse.

I discussed this a few days back when Deadspin broke the news that Jay Mariotti had signed up to be a “columnist” at FanHouse. I had a little fun with Photoshop, sent out a bunch of tips so I would have other people to commiserate with, and mentally prepared myself for being part of a blogosphere that new includes Jay Mariotti.

And then I waited for the first vitriolic, back-stabbing, contradictory, and nonsensical article from America’s most hated sportswriter. And, as to be expected, Jay did not disappoint. Check out Deadspin’s summary of the first Jay Mariotti column at FanHouse, and feel free to follow the link they provide to view the column for yourself.

I refuse to link you to the Mariotti column, as it is my goal to never be the linking source for one referral to the new Mariotti blog. Ozzie Guillen and Hawk Harrelson would be proud of me for this; and while I realize that there are many people who view Ozzie and Hawk in the same light as Mariotti, I respectfully and strongly disagree. Perhaps my die-hard love for the Chicago White Sox clouds objective judgment, but that is the last caveat you will get from me. I don’t like Jay Mariotti, I never have, and I know that millions of sports fans across America (including and especially these guys) agree with me and that we all have very sound and rational reasons for our feelings about Jay Mariotti.

I almost feel like I’m wasting my time and your time writing any more about Jay Mariotti’s first column at FanHouse. So I will just leave you with an image that pretty sums up the reputation that Jay Mariotti has earned over his many years of being an incendiary and ridiculous clown of a sports writer.

First Jay Mariotti Column Gets Hyped-Down by Many

The image above is a screen capture taken earlier today of the front page of BallHype. Anyone who frequents BallHype, as I do, knows that very rarely do posts get hyped down on BallHype. Typically, if someone dislikes or does not care about a post, it is just ignored. And as you can see from the vast majority of posts listed on the front page today, this trend held true.

Until, of course, you reached the BallHype entry for the first Jay Mariotti column at FanHouse.

Look at the way at the bottom of the image and you will notice an entry with a drop shadow behind it and a frightening picture of a smiling turd beside it. Then look at the stats: 20 hype-ups, and 8 hype-downs. 8! I do not recall ever seeing more than two hype-downs on a single post. Incredibly, I was actually surprised that Mariotti’s post had not received more hype-downs than it did.

Anyway, the weather is cold and gloomy here in Dallas, with near-freezing temperatures and frozen rain in the forecast for the evening. The meteorologists are blaming an “arctic front” or some BS like that. I blame Jay Mariotti.

Thank you for commiserating with me. Now if you’ll excuse me, I have an article to go hype-down.

(Update: Just checked a few hours after posting this and the BallHype entry about Jay Mariotti’s first FanHouse post is now at 10 hype-downs. Congratulations on your triumphant return to sports writing Jay!)



Tony Dungy Retirement Rumors Escalate – Bob Kravitz Column Way Off Base

Email Post Email Post
sports15

Tony Dungy Retirement Rumors EscalateI actually have to get back to day job today, so updates will be a little more sparse. However, I’ve seen some news this morning regarding the escalating rumors of Tony Dungy’s possible retirement.

I have already gone on record as saying that I hope Tony Dungy does not retire. Bob Kravitz of the Indianapolis Star obviously disagrees with me; and from the looks of the comments section of the article, he disagrees with about 99% of the Colts fan base as well.

An email exchange I had with a major sports blog earlier today summed it up the best. I emailed them a link to Kravitz article as a tip, hoping they would post it so sports fans around the world could view Kravitz’s drivel and realize what sports fans in Indy have to put up with. Their response: “What a buffoon.” I couldn’t have said it any better myself.

One line in particular stood out to me in Kravitz’s article about Tony Dungy: “As much as we all respect and like the man, the numbers cannot be ignored.” Kravitz then follows this up by discussing Dungy’s disappointing playoff record. The truth though is that Kravitz is right, the numbers cannot be ignored, he was just right for a reason in opposition of his main point. Tony Dungy’s record as Colts head coach, the numbers, make it implausible for any Colts observer to say the franchise is better off without him. Six straight 12-win seasons, a plus-.750 winning percentage, a Super Bowl championship — the numbers are in Dungy’s favor, not working against him.

And, of course, Bob Kravitz seems to contradict himself by essentially saying that Colts fans would be stuck Indianapolis Star Columnist Bob Kravitz off base as Tony Dungy retirement rumors escalatewith Jim Caldwell, and that “the Colts should understand turning to Caldwell will be a tough sell.” Why then is it in the team’s best interest for Tony Dungy to go? If the already determined successor is “Tony Dungy Lite” and would prove a tough sell, how does the franchise improve by Tony Dungy leaving?

Is Bob Kravitz confusing anyone else? If I’m off base here, please tell me. My head was spinning after reading the Kravitz column because it just did not seem to make any coherent sense.

Mike Florio at ProFootballTalk has an interesting take on the issue, while claiming that sources around the Colts say its about 70-30 that Dungy will, in fact, retire:

In a city where the Colts often keep the primary newspaper in town on a choke chain, Kravitz (in our view) wouldn’t be sliding out onto that specific limb unless he already knows what Dungy is going to do.

Of course, there’s also a chance that Kravitz has gotten a nudge from G.M. Bill Polian, who might want to use the transition to a new head coach as cover for the team’s looming struggles in the last capped year under the current CBA, which for the Colts will be the day of reckoning after years of pushing cap dollars into future seasons.

I suppose a gentle nudge from Bill Polian might explain what I consider to be a pretty nonsensical article by Bob Kravitz, but I am having a hard time believing that would be true. Of course, Florio has posted some pretty unflattering remarks about Bill Polian in the past, much to the dismay of some Colts supporters. I’ll be honest and say that I don’t know enough about the situation to accurately comment; but the notion that a GM would give a “nudge” to a local columnist to write a negative article about the most successful coach in franchise history is, well, interesting. I’ll put it that way.

The Colts obviously have some questions heading into 2009, none more important than the status of their current head coach and if he will be there next season. As the Tony Dungy retirement rumors continue to escalate, I just hope we do not see any more stories like the one penned by Bob Kravitz. Tony Dungy deserves far more respect, and not just because he is a good and decent man; but because he is without the question the best person to lead the Colts as head coach for next season. Colts fans and interested observers like myself are anxiously awaiting his final decision, and hopefully we don’t have to sift through any more Kravitzesque drivel while keeping up with the latest Tony Dungy updates.

What do you think? Is Bob Kravitz off base in his criticism of Tony Dungy?

Are the Indianapolis Colts better off without Tony Dungy as head coach?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...


NFL Playoffs Divisional Round Matchups – TV Schedule and Announcer Pairings

Email Post Email Post

NFL Playoffs Divisional Round TV Schedule - Announcer Pairings - Point Spreads - Over-Under OddsWild Card Weekend of the NFL Playoffs has ended, and now its time for the final eight teams to square off in the Divisional Round.

Unfortunately, the two teams that I was rooting for in the AFC, the Dolphins and Colts, both fell short. However, both Baltimore and San Diego are exciting teams who should provide solid matchups to the top seeds, Pittsburgh and Tennessee.

In the NFC, the Eagles win over the Vikings sets up the marquee matchup of the Divisional Round when Philadelphia travels to NFC East division rival and #1 seed New York. If you can only watch one game this weekend, I would think that would be the one you would watch.

Well, as we always do here at Midwest Sports Fans, we get you ready for the matchups of this upcoming weekend’s action with the TV Schedule, announcer lineups, point spreads, and over-under odds for the Divisional Round games.

As usual, the point spreads are provided by BetUs.com. And my projections for the announcer lineups were correct, as confirmed by Awful Announcing.


Divisional Round Matchups | TV Schedule – Announcer Pairings – Point Spreads

__________

Divisional Round Playoff Games on Saturday, January 10, 2009

Baltimore Ravens (12-5) at Tennessee Titans (13-3)


Arizona Cardinals (10-7) at Carolina Panthers (12-4)

  • TV Schedule: 8:15 ET on FOX
  • Announcer Pairing: Kenny Albert, Daryl Johnston, and Tony Siragusa
  • Point Spread: Carolina Panthers -10 1/2
  • Over-Under Odds: 48 1/2

__________

Divisional Round Playoff Games on Sunday, January 11, 2009

Philadelphia Eagles (10-6-1) at New York Giants (12-4)

  • TV Schedule: 1:00 ET on FOX
  • Announcer Pairing: Joe Buck, Troy Aikman, and Pam Oliver
  • Point Spread: New York Giants -4 1/2
  • Over-Under Odds: 40

San Diego Chargers (9-8) at Pittsburgh Steelers (12-4)

  • TV Schedule: 4:45 ET on CBS
  • Announcer Pairing: Jim Nantz and Phil Simms
  • Point Spread: Pittsburgh Steelers -6 1/2
  • Over-Under Odds: 38


LOTD: Kansas City Chiefs GM the Best Job In Football Says Jason Whitlock

Email Post Email Post

LOTD: Kansas City Chiefs GM Job Best in NFL says WhitlockIt has been an interesting day in the NFL today. The wild card round of the playoffs has wrapped up with a Philadelphia win, coming on the heels of the Ravens trashing the Dolphins earlier today. Additionally, there has been a plethora of new stories that have emerged regarding the job openings in Cleveland and Kansas City, among others.

The most interesting story of the day, at least from my perspective, is one written by Jason Whitlock of the Kansas City Star.

Whitlock says that the person hired by Clark Hunt to be the next Chiefs GM will be getting the best job in football. As to who might get that job, Whitlock cites Kevin Colbert, Chris Polian, and Randy Lerner’s reported favorite for the Browns GM job: Scott Pioli.

What is Whitlock’s reasoning for why each of these men has “more reason to pursue Clark Hunt than Hunt has to pursue them”?

  • The Hunt family employed Carl Peterson for 20 years, demonstrating a level of loyalty and patience that is pretty much nonexistent in professional sports.
  • The Hunts gave Peterson a degree of autonomy that is pretty much nonexistent in professional sports.
  • The Chiefs are more than $30 million below the salary cap and are in position to unload a few more unproductive, expensive veterans this offseason.
  • The Chiefs are one season away from playing in a fancy, exciting, renovated Arrowhead Stadium.
  • There’s no one within the football side of the organization that a new GM has to show any loyalty. He can clean out the scouting department and coaching staff.
  • Expectations are low.

I have to say that Whitlock’s reasoning is rather convincing. The Chiefs GM job certainly is not the best for a GM looking to win next year, although the Dolphins and Falcons proved this year that miraculous one-year turnarounds are possible; however, from a long-term standpoint, it is hard to argue that any GM would be getting a sweet gig in K.C.

As always, don’t just take my word for it. Be sure to visit the LOTD:

Chiefs GM Job is the Best Job in Football Says Jason Whitlock – (Kansas City Star)

I would obviously love to argue with Whitlock, and say that the Browns GM job would be better than Kansas City. Considering the troubles the Browns have experienced since coming back into the NFL, however, it is very hard to posit such an argument. And considering that Randy Lerner appears to now be seriously considering a new regime that would include a former Ravens personnel guy as GM and a former Patriots assistant as coach, I have to wonder exactly what the thought process is at the top of the Browns organization.

Remember, I said a new regime. If this article in the Plain-Dealer sounds familiar with you, it’s because the Savage-Crennel combo came to the Browns with pretty much the same background as the potential Mangini-Kokinis regime that Lerner seems excited about, save for Eric Mangini’s three years of head coaching experience that Crennel never had.

I still want to see Scott Pioli become the next Browns GM, but the way the things have dragged out, as well as his impending interview with Kansas City, has tempered by excitement somewhat this Pioli-to-the-Browns can become a reality. We’ll see.

Also, to update Midnight Writer’s earlier post from today that Bill Parcells-to-the-Browns could be a realistic possibility, the Miami-Herald posted an item earlier today suggesting that Parcells has already made assurances that he will stay in Miami. Obviously, the thought of Bill Parcells taking control of the Browns is exciting, and the Miami-Herald item would seem to kill the excitement. Luckily, Mike Florio over at Pro Football Talk keeps the dream alive by questioning just how much this story should be believed. His rationale seems reasonable to me. Of course, I may not be the most rational judge of the issue, as my wishful thinking could be clouding objectivity.

That’s it for now. Have a great Sunday night.



What Options do the Minnesota Twins Have Left This Offseason?

Email Post Email Post

The Minnesota Twins Current Salaries and Payroll Situation:Minnesota Twins 2009 Payroll and Salaries

C – Joe Mauer – $10.5MM

1B – Justin Morneau – $10.6MM

2B – Alexi Casilla – $450K

3B – Brendan Harris/Brian Buscher – $450K

SS – Nick Punto – 4.25M

LF – Delmon Young – $700K

CF – Denard Span – $400K

RF – Michael Cuddyer – $6.75MM

DH – Jason Kubel – $1.3MM+

SP – Scott Baker – $423K

SP – Francisco Liriano – $400K

SP – Kevin Slowey – $400K

SP – Nick Blackburn – $400K

SP – Glen Perkins – $400K

RP – Joe Nathan – $11.25MM

RP – Jesse Crain – $1.7MM

RP – Matt Guerrier – $950K+

RP – Pat Neshek – $435K

RP – Boof Bonser – $433K

RP – Craig Breslow – $400K

RP – Jose Mijares – $400K

Bench – C – Mike Redmond – 950K

Bench – 3B – Brendan Harris/Brian Buscher – $450K

Bench – IF – Matt Tolbert – $400K

Bench – OF – Carlos Gomez – $400K

Others on Payroll: Mike Lamb – $3MM

That’s a full 25 man roster tallying to a cool $58.2 million dollars.

In 2007 before we let go of Hunter, Santana and Silva’s contracts, our team salary was at $71.4 million dollars, quite a bit higher than the 58.2 million we stand at now. It would appear as if we should have room to spend and that our team payroll could be anywhere from $70–80 million if management decided to spend at previous years’ numbers plus increase, leaving $12-22 million dollars of unspent payroll.

Ty Wigginton a Target of the Minnesota Twins at 3B

So what would our options be?

1. Trade for Adrian Beltre at 3B – Should be at a price $12 million next year and players (possibly a mix of Cuddyer/Perkins/Prospect)? Beltre added the Twins to his no-trade clause list most likely by recommendation of his agent Scott Boras in order to have bargaining chips down the road (i.e. compensation for waiving his no trade clause).

2. Sign Ty Wigginton at 3B – Expect $6-8 million/yr and 3 years plus based on Ty wanting a bigger contract than Casey Blake’s 3 year $17.5 million dollar deal to the Dodgers. Talks seem to have come to a halt in December and the Indians have shown interest.

3. Sign Joe Crede at 3B – Could go anywhere from $2-6 million based on his health and where the market for him is at in a month. The Giants seem to think he’s healthy enough to start pursuing. Should only be a one year deal.

4. Trade for Garrett Atkins at 3B – Salary in the $5 million dollar per year range. Rockies are asking quite a bit for him though (Slowey + Prospects).

So it looks like after the Blake and DeRosa talks fell through we’ve run a little thin on options. Unless we take a good stab at Ty Wigginton and give him a 3rd year, I believe we’ll be looking at another year of the Harris/Buscher platoon. Joe Crede’s another option that I think is viable, we just haven’t heard much about it from the Twins camp and depending on his health he probably wouldn’t be much of an impact. The Garrett Atkins deal just asks way too much from the Twins (no way the Twins give up Slowey for just about anyone at this point).

The Adrian Beltre option, if it went down as described, is preferred but would be a one year rental (plus this means having Scott Boras around which is certainly not something the Twins want to have on their plate). Grabbing Adrian Beltre though, even in a rental situation, makes this team incredibly dangerous and may be this team’s hope for a World Series run. Unfortunately, Seattle probably wants more than described above and are rumored to be unreasonable in the negotiations around a Beltre deal.

—-

Guys I would be looking to deal:Nick Blackburn - Minnesota Twins

Cuddyer – Big contract and we’re overstocked in the outfield.

Punto – Poor production and unfortunately a new big contract.

Perkins – The weakest of our young starting pitching staff. We have a lot of talent in the minors.

Kubel – If the price was right.

Harris/Buscher – If anybody wanted them in a package and we got a 3B in return.

Guys I would NOT be looking to deal:

Liriano/Slowey/Baker/Blackburn – All young cheap studs. Very underrated pitching staff. Many would argue Blackburn is in the “deal” mix if the price was right, but his performance in the play-in game was stellar. When October rolls around this guy will come to play.

Gomez/Young/Span – This is the future of our outfield. Young and loaded with talent.

Mauer/Morneau – For obvious reasons.

Casilla – Young, talented, fast, and versatile with a decent bat. Can’t look for much more out of a guy playing 2nd base these days.

Nick Punto, Minnesota TwinsSpeaking of Nick Punto’s new contract: Since when have the Twins overspent on somebody this much? A guy that hit .284 with 2 dingers last year (not to mention a .210 batting average the year before with nearly 500 AB’s!) can not be worth over 4 million a year. Now that the Cubs have signed a similar player in Aaron Miles to a deal half that of Punto’s (Miles has slightly more attractive stats including a .317 average last season) some Twins fans, including myself, have found themselves a little perplexed. Why would we give Punto such a big contract? Maybe he’s just that much of a “gamer” and has too much defensive ability to deny. Maybe he’s just simply that integral to our team chemistry. Maybe it’s just that inspiring to the clubhouse that when he actually hits a home run, it rallies our team for months. Maybe the Twins just have that much of an infatuation with him, knowing that we should trade him away, we signed him to a big contract in hopes some other team takes it on after we deal him away (for say J.J. Hardy, fair?) giving Nick some extra cash. Whatever the case, the contract was too big for a guy who it can be debated whether or not should have a starting job in the major leagues. I love the guy as a competitor, but his numbers are killing us. Fun fact: Nick Punto will be making roughly twice that of our entire starting rotation next year.

Another guy that we should hold onto and that’s been in dozens of rumors is Delmon Young. Ron Gardenhire was quoted in December as saying our starting lineup next year would consist of Span, Gomez, and Cuddyer obviously leaving out the former 1st overall pick Delmon Young. This seemingly opened the door for Young to be dealt and the rumors flew in. Delmon Young - Minnesota Twins

Wait a minute…

Yes he only hit 10 homers and yes he only hit .290 last year. But, the guy did that as a 22 year old in the majors. At 22! It seems like sometimes we drool over prospects that do that in the minors at the same age. I would hope we give him plenty time to develop being that there aren’t many guys in the game with as high of a ceiling as Delmon. He’s the definition of a low risk, high potential type of player that I would think the Twins would love to have. Worst case scenario, he doesn’t pan out and we pull one of our talented guys playing well in the minors up to fill in, but I really think this guy could do us wonders in a few years as long as his attitude problems are kept in check.

I’m certainly hoping that the Gardenhire quote was a ploy to increase Cuddyer’s trade value.

In other AL Central news today:

Former White Sox Outfielder Ken Griffey Jr. could be heading back to the Mariners.



Browns Banter: Rumors Swirl That Bill Parcells May Be Interested in Coming to Cleveland

Email Post Email Post
bill-parcells

Bill Parcells-Browns rumors swirl in ClevelandNewest rumor coming out of South Florida: Bill Parcells, Scott Pioli’s father-in-law, has directed Pioli to interview with the Kansas City Chiefs. An interview has apparently been scheduled.

In the meantime, Bill Parcells, a kind of NFL Fix-It Man mixed with Powerful Mafia Boss, may take his option and get out of Miami and head up north.

To Cleveland.

If this is true, it would be a better deal than Cleveland landing LeBron James. Bill Parcells at the helm as Browns president and who ever the heck Parcells wants.

Another rumor floating out there is that Mike Shanahan may be the best fit for a Cleveland Browns coach.

Word is, Parcells has many friends among the Italian-Americans living in Cleveland.

Unfortunately, just for today, I will root for Baltimore to beat Miami.

Maybe there is a Football God, after all.

(Editor’s Note: I have heard from a few people that there was a radio interview on a local Cleveland station today that posited exactly what Midnight Writer explains in this post: that Bill Parcells very well may be interested in the Cleveland job, should he opt out of his position with the Dolphins. With speculation swirling that the new Dolphins owner could bring in friend Carl Peterson, despite his public pronouncements that he wants Parcells to stay, it could help motivate Bill Parcells to seek out a new turnaround job in another city.

I honestly don’t quite know what to make of this yet, but the thought of Bill Parcells in Cleveland, working his magic yet again, is certainly an intriguing possibility.)

Update: Check out today’s LOTD for a new update regarding the Parcells-to-Browns rumor that was floating early today. The update is near the bottom of the story.



As Indianapolis Colts 2008 Season Ends, There Are Major Questions for 2009

Email Post Email Post

Indianapolis Colts 2009 Offseason Questions - Salary Cap SituationLast night, the 2008 season of the Indianapolis Colts came to a grinding halt in San Diego as Philip Rivers, Darren Sproles, and the Charges upended the Colts in overtime 23-17.

The Colts have been amazingly consistent this decade, with this past season standing out because of its roller-coaster nature. Peyton Manning had to have knee surgery during the preseason, the team stumbled to a 3-4 start, they never found a consistent ground game, dealt with injuries all season long, and somehow racked up nine straight wins, another MVP for Manning, and cruised into the playoffs once again.

After going 3-13 in 1998, the Colts have had only one losing season in the last ten (2001, 6-10). And 2008 marked the team’s sixth straight season of tallying 12 or more wins. Tony Dungy, who took over the Colts from former head coach Jim Mora in 2002, has compiled an 85-28 record in Indianapolis; that’s a winning percentage of greater than 75%.

Wow.

As the 2008 season of the Indianapolis Colts ends, however, there are many questions heading into 2009. The answers to these questions will ultimately provide the answer to overriding question facing the Colts franchise: Can the Colts possibly continue their incredibly consistent year-in, year-out performance?

Let’s run down a few of the most pressing questions:

1 — Will Tony Dungy return as coach?

Tony Dungy has made no secret of the fact that he has considered retirement every year since the Colts won the Super Bowl. As the Colts playoff game against the Chargers approached this past week, speculation about a potential Tony Dungy retirement began swirling again. Dungy has said that we will take at least a week to unwind from the season and see how he feels. If he does decide to retire, the Colts have already named Jim Caldwell the head-coach-in-waiting.

There is no doubt that if Dungy decides to retire, his imprint will still define the Indianapolis Colts in 2009. I have read a few different places that the Colts may just be ready for Tony Dungy to retire, in hopes of avoiding a Favresque Will-He-or-Won’t-He scenario. I don’t really buy that. The Colts have a succession plan already in place, and will move in that direction should Dungy decide it is his time to go. But they will welcome him back with open arms as long as he wants to continue coaching. I hope that he does, and I know that Colts fans everywhere agree.

2 — What will happen with Marvin Harrison?

Mike Florio at Pro Football Talk posted an interesting item earlier today regarding Marvin Harrison’s exorbitant cap number for next season. Currently, that cap number is $13.4 million. If he was the Marvin Harrison of old, one of the best receivers in the NFL, that amount might be palatable. But for the declining version we saw this season, a shell of the dominant receiver Colts fans remember, there is no way the Colts can afford that much for Harrison. By cutting Marvin Harrison, as Florio points out, the Colts could free up $7 million in 2009.

More importantly, at least I think, is will Marvin Harrison even be a free man when the 2009 season comes around? Do not forget that there are still pending charges against Marvin Harrison for a shooting that took place in his hometown of Philadelphia in March of 2008. Colts fans always get mad when I bring this up, and many think this is a closed case simply because the DA’s office in Philly has not yet pushed forward, but make no mistake: this case is not over.

I am keeping an eye on this case, because sources close to the investigation say it could come to a head sometime during the first few months of 2009. Just as the New York GIants face uncertainty with the legal status of Plaxico Burress, the Colts face similar questions with Marvin Harrison; and in the end, these issues could actually make the Colts’ decision regarding Harrison’s cap number quite simple.

3 — What will the Colts do to get under the 2009 salary cap?

Another post by Mike Florio at PFT today goes into a little more detail regarding the effect of Peyton Manning’s monster contract on the Colts’ no-so-good salary cap status heading into 2009. Peyton Manning’s $21.2 million salary cap number for 2009 accounts for 17% of the team’s expected spending of $123 million; and makes Harrison’s cap number seem miniscule in comparison. (Of course, Peyton Manning is still highly productive and playing at an MVP level, while Harrison is nowhere close to being that valuable to the team.)

As Florio points out in the Marvin Harrison post, the Colts are projected to be $2.5 million over the expected $123 million cap for 2009. This is not unexpected, of course, as the Colts’ philosophy is to build their team around highly-paid superstars (Manning, Harrison, Wayne, Freeney, Sanders) and then fill in the gaps with younger players playing closer to the minimum. The drawback to this strategy is the expected reduction of depth, but the Colts proved this season that they were able to develop solid depth even with younger, lesser-paid backups.

Luckily for the Colts, most of their key players are signed through next season. Their free agents after the 2008 season, all unrestricted, are Matt Giordana, Keiwan Ratliff, Dominic Rhodes, Jeff Saturday, and Josh Thomas. You have to think that the Colts will want to resign Saturday, but for how much? He is getting up there in years and has been more prone to injury lately. Dominic Rhodes proved to be a very valuable backup to the oft-injured Joseph Addai. And Keiwan Ratliff and Matt Giordano provide good depth in the secondary.

Oh yeah, and the Colts have to sign their rookies too.

Thus, the Colts will be in dire need of the $7 million they can save by cutting Marvin Harrison, and may have to ask stars like Peyton Manning to take less money in 2009 for the best interest of the team. These monetary concerns, and how the Colts decide to deal with them, will define what the Colts look like in 2009.

4 – The running game

The Colts struggled all season to run the ball effectively. Part of this was due to injuries along the offensive line, as well as nagging injuries that seemed to hinder Joseph Addai all season long. The lack of a consistent running game made life that much more difficult for the Colts offense and Peyton Manning. Manning’s ability to overcome the inconsistent running attack was one reason why he won the MVP; but something tells me he would much rather have the luxury of a dependable running game in 2009.

Obviously, these are only a few of the many questions that the Colts must answer heading in 2009. But they are probably the most important. The first domino will be Tony Dungy, and then we’ll have to see how the rest of them fall from there.

Time to go watch the Dolphins. Have a great Sunday everyone.



Jay Mariotti Joins Fanhouse as Blogger and Sports Fans Collectively Weep

Email Post Email Post
mariotti-blogger

Earlier today I saw news posted on Deadspin that I had been dreading for some time now: Jay Mariotti has returned to the sports world as he has now joined FanHouse as a blogger. Unfortunately for all of us, Jay Mariotti has a national voice again, and the sports world is far worse off for it.

And apparently Jay Mariotti has already retreated to his mom’s basement in his underwear to write his first post for FanHouse:

(Photo Art by Midwest Sports Fans)

Jay Mariotti Joins FanHouse as Blogger

You may remember that back when Jay Mariotti resigned from the Chicago Sun-Times, I joined the chorus of sports fans basically telling Jay not let the door him in the ass on the way out of Chicago. Famed movie critic Roger Ebert actually said this specifically.

Our posts about Jay Mariotti provided me with the accomplishment that I take the most pride in during Midwest Sports Fans’ five months of existence: if you google “Jay Mariotti douche bag”, Midwest Sports Fans is the #1 hit. No matter what else we ever achieve here at MSF, it is quite possible that nothing will top that.

I have to run, but I do plan to add more to this post later. The irony of Jay Mariotti joining FanHouse and becoming a member of the blogging community to which I just recently joined, as well as the dread of Jay Mariotti having a national voice again, simply begs for more exposition.

Until then, take part in the poll and give us your thoughts on Jay Mariotti’s douchebaggery:

Am I being too harsh by calling Jay Mariotti a douche bag?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

And I’m back.

In the specific interest of completely piling on Jay Mariotti, let’s take a look at some of the memorable blog posts that have been dedicated to Chicago’s worst ever sports writer.

First off, how about the official announcement from Chicago Sun-Times Editor in Chief Michael Cooke when Mariotti announced his resignation from the Sun-Times. The announcement includes this little gem, proving that Jay Mariotti had endeared himself to his former colleagues about as much as he did to sports fans nationwide:

We wish Jay well and will miss him — not personally, of course — but in the sense of noticing he is no longer here, at least for a few days.

Sounds they were really broken up about Jay’s departure.

And how about this amazing 2005 Jay Mariotti Year in Review, written by Eric Zorn of the Chicago Tribune. Here are a few of the highlights, taken verbatim from Mariotti’s column during the White Sox drive to the 2005 World Series title:

April 7th – (The Sox are) Winning Lucky. Groovy as Sox life seems right now, let me assure you that this is no formula for a division title.

April 23rd – Guillen is only confirming what his critics said: He’s too nuts, off the wall and out of control.

May 15th – (The Sox) have the sweetest rotation in the sport ….And while I’m not about to predict they’ll be the first local team in 187 collective seasons to win a World Series, they are built to last deep into September.

June 7th – I can safely say the Sox won’t win a World Series as long as (Jerry Reinsdorf) owns them.

June 24th – Guillen’s feistiness has a magical effect on the Sox.

June 30th – Williams insists the Sox don’t need major roster surgery, but I couldn’t disagree more.

August 17th – You might be under the influence of Hawk Harrelson, but for non-homers who analyze baseball at face value, the Sox are vulnerable because their attack lacks punch.

September 1st – Who is Geoff Blum, anyway?

September 18th – If there is any sense of mercy, the White Sox will be blacked out the rest of the season so a terminally cursed city needn’t witness The Mother of All Collapses.

September 20th – Other cities host the World Series. Chicago hosts Choke Job Theater.

September 27th – Just why are the Sox playing for October when they clearly don ‘ t belong there?

October 4th – I’ve been trying to tell out-of-towners that Guillen has been a terrific manager.

October 21st – They’ve won with the kind of smart, unselfish, high-character, pitching-and-defense charm that defies everything we’ve seen from baseball in recent seasons….The Sox are about pure baseball.

October 27th – What they did, thanks to the feisty leadership of Guillen and foresight of Williams, was write a new blueprint on how baseball might be played in the post-steroids era.

Is your head spinning yet from all of the contradictions? And from all of the horribly erroneous predictions and comments? And seriously, these few excerpts don’t even do the entire post justice. Here is the link again, go read it: Jay Mariotti 2005 Year in Review.

And how about Jay Mariotti on Chicago Bears head coach Lovie Smith? You guessed it. More blowharding and more contradictions. And once again we have Eric Zorn, my new personal hero, to thank for pointing it out:

All I know is, a man named Lovie cannot coach the world-famous Chicago Bears …Sun-Times columnist Jay Mariotti, Jan. 14, 2004

Lovie Smith, racking up Coach of the Year votes by the week…Sun-Time columnist Jay Mariotti, November 14, 2005

Honestly, I could probably do this all night long and never get bored. I realize that I have made some pretty strong statements and been proven wrong numerous times. However, unlike Dr. Douchebaggery himself, I usually point out my mistakes and take responsibility for them. Jay Mariotti simply stands in defiant opposition of any critics, wafting in the sweet (at least to him) smell of his putrid, gaseous hot air.

So, congratulations to FanHouse for bringing in Jay Mariotti. I’m sure he will draw a lot of traffic simply because of his name and fame, and his willingness to say anything at any time, without any hint of shame when his thoughts, predictions, and diatribes are proven to be horribly wrong or off base.

I wonder how the guys over at Jay the Joke feel about this?



Browns Head Coach-GM Update: Eric Mangini Reportedly the Clubhouse Leader

Email Post Email Post

Browns: Eric Mangini the Front-Runner to Become Head Coach of the Cleveland BrownsLast week, I wrote a lengthy diatribe imploring Browns owner Randy Lerner not to hire Eric Mangini. My reasoning had nothing to do with Mangini being a terrible coach, and everything to do with the exigence of Randy Lerner making a hire that gives Browns hope and a sense of optimism heading into next year.

Hiring a recently fired coach who has the same New England coaching pedigree of our own recently fired coach is not my idea of renewing hope. Plus, I just don’t see Mangini’s aloof arrogance playing well in Cleveland, no matter how brilliant of a football tactician he may be.

Well, it looks like Randy Lerner does not pay attention to Midwest Sports Fans when deciding who to hire as head coach. (And, honestly, let’s all thank the good Lord for that.)

The latest report today from Chris Mortensen at ESPN is that Eric Mangini is now the leading candidate to become the head coach of the Cleveland Browns. Additionally, Mort’s report says that Mangini could be hired as part of a package deal with a GM whose name is not Scott Pioli:

The Browns have continued their search process, interviewing other candidates, but sources say Mangini had a “compelling” interview and owner Randy Lerner is fascinated with him.

If Mangini gets the job to replace the fired Romeo Crennel, the favorite to become the team’s general manager is George Kokinis, who is the director of pro personnel for the Baltimore Ravens, the sources said.

Kokinis and Mangini each were members of the Browns organization when Bill Belichick was coach. Mangini formally joined the staff as an assistant coach in 1995. Kokinis was a scout from 1991 to 1995 before moving with the team to Baltimore.

This is obviously a very fluid situation, with new candidates seeming to emerge by the day and purported deadlines coming and going with now decisions ultimately being made. Thus, I don’t want to waste time speculating anymore on who the next Browns head coach and GM will be. I have made my feelings about Eric Mangini known, as well as my preference for Scott Pioli, even if it means Iowa’s Kirk Ferentz becomes the Browns’ new head coach. I think it’s now time to just sit back and see how it all shakes out before I waste my time typing about it anymore.

However, if you want to know all of the latest reports, here are some recent links for you to check out:

Mangini is the leader, but beware of unnamed sources in Browns head coach/GM search – (Pro Football Talk)

Is Pioli taking a page out of father-in-law Parcells’ book by maximizing leverage? – (Pro Football Talk) – Interesting post in which Florio echoes what I’ve been saying: that Browns fans are not going to want Mangini (nor another former Ravens personnel guy as GM) because we’ve been there, done that.

Mike Shanahan puts off Browns for two weeks, candidacy likely over in Cleveland – (Plain-Dealer)

Josh McDaniels and Mel Tucker make their case to become Browns head coach – (Plain-Dealer)

Browns like Mangini and Pioli; Can they get both? – (Plain-Dealer)

Latest News and Rumors on the Browns coach/GM search – (Orange and Brown Report – pay for the premium service, by the way. It’s worth it.)

Rumor of package deal with Ferentz makes Scott Pioli not look like such a good choice – (Dawg Pound Daily)

So there you go. I have heard from a few different sources that something will be happening with Scott Pioli imminently, and of course nothing has happened yet. I am going to watch the IU-Iowa game, and then the Colts-Chargers game, and try not to worry about the frustrating roller-coaster ride that has been Randy Lerner’s search for a new GM and head coach. Of course, if something definitive actually happens, I’m sure I’ll hop on here and get you updated.

All I know “for sure” is this: Eric Mangini definitely appears to be front-runner for the Browns head coaching job, and I don’t like it any more today than I did earlier this week. And if it precludes the Browns from getting Scott Pioli, I like it even less.

But it’s time to stop worrying at this point — and just start waiting. Randy Lerner wants to get something done quickly, so hopefully it will.

Weren’t things much more tidy and exciting when everyone was assuming Bill Cowher would be coming to town? Oh the good ‘ol days…



LOTD: Is Scott Pioli Being Prematurely Anointed as a Great NFL GM and Savior?

Email Post Email Post

Is Scott Pioli Being Prematurely Anointed as a Great NFL GM?I have been quite outspoken in my support of the Browns’ pursuit of New England VP of Player Personnel Scott Pioli to be the next GM in Cleveland. However, other very informed and rational Browns fans have certainly disagreed with my assessment.

Today’s LOTD (Link of the Day, if you are not yet familiar with our newest feature here at MSF) brings an entirely different perspective, and comes to us from SFTSports.com:

Now that Scott Pioli of the Patriots seems to have his pick of GM jobs for some teams that suck (that would be the Browns and the Chiefs if you haven’t been paying attention), I have a couple questions. Pioli seemingly has done wonders as VP of Player Personnel, but let’s be honest: as important as it may be, he’s not held the GM position. And how much of Pioli’s success can be directly correlated to Bill Belichick’s coaching? I get the sense that Pioli could draw a QB’s name out of a hat when he’s evaluating talent and have that guy get to the Pro Bowl via the scheme in place in New England where seemingly average players suddenly become better.

Anybody else remember a couple of years ago when everyone thought Charlie Weis and Romeo Crennel were the greatest coaches alive? They won Super Bowls with the Patriots and have perfected losing since leaving. I’m not saying Pioli will be a bust by any means, but I’m saying let’s not order Super Bowl rings anytime soon for the team he goes to. I think Pioli could possibly end up like any of these young talents below who may have been prematurely thrust into the “great” category before we really saw their whole career play out:

To view the entertaining list of celebrities and athletes who were prematurely anointed as great, which may just be happening in the case of Scott Pioli, you’ll have to head on over to SFTSports. And I highly encourage you to do so. The link is below.

Link of the Day: Scott Pioli Premature Anointing List – (SFTSports.com)

And now some other entertaining links for you on a beautiful Saturday here in Dallas, as I await the first Big Ten game for the Indiana Hoosiers in what could be…ugh…and very long conference season.

Commiserate with other IU fans at this Indiana-Iowa Live Blog – (Inside the Hall)

Eric Gordon backing new AAU team – (IDS Basketblog)

White Sox and Orioles discussing Gavin Floyd-Brian Roberts Deal – (South Side Sox)

No one knows when Rasheed Wallace and Rip Hamilton will be back – (Hardcore Detroit Fan)

SB Nation’s NFL 2008 Studs and Duds – (Stampede Blue)

It’s Time to Go For Brett Favre – (SFTSports.com)

Failure of Detroit Lions is No Coincidence – (Bleacher Report)

Colts-Chargers Wild Card Preview – (Bolts From the Blue)

Does Jerry Jones Want Mike Shanahan? – (Dallas Sports Fans)

Jason Whitlock is not amused by Deadspin or Rick Reilly – (Deadspin)

Enjoy your Saturday everyone.



Minnesota Twins Offseason Recap | Joe Mauer Has Kidney Surgery

Email Post Email Post
twins-logo

(Editor’s note: All of us at Midwest Sports Fans would like to welcome Tyler George to the writing crew. Tyler will be covering the Minnesota Twins, beginning with his first post today: an recap of the Minnesota Twins offseason activity and a quick update on Joe Mauer’s kidney surgery.)

Minnesota Twins Offseason Recap | Joe Mauer Kidney SurgeryTwins fans, if you’ve been hibernating this offseason apparently you’re not alone; the front office has been napping right beside you. In an offseason where it’s obvious we need to upgrade before April 6th, we’ve talked big and done very little. So here’s your recap of the last few months:

–The Twins re-signed Nick Punto to a 2 year 8 million dollar contract.

–The Twins signed knuckleballer R.A. Dickey to a minor league deal.

That’s it.

Surprised?

From the sounds of it, names like Adrian Beltre, Ty Wiggington, J.J. Hardy, Casey Blake, Joe Crede, Mark DeRosa and Michael Young, among others, have been thrown around on various rumor boards; but as we stand now, every major lead has come to a dead end. And this by no means is anything new for the Twins fan out there.

We’ve watched Minnesota dump big name players year in and year out to make room for other up and coming stars. However, what makes this year frustrating is that we’re not seeing the payroll gain from the losses of Santana, Hunter, and Silva being reinvested in the team. We’re just watching each FA opportunity fall to the wayside while we have the makings of a great team that needs just a little more to get over the hump.

So what is it that we need?

It’s simple: upgrades at the left side of the infield and relief help.

Now that Minnesota’s re-signed Punto, (unfortunately, Ron Gardenhire insists that he will be the Opening Day starter) we need to look at 3B to replace the Harris/Buscher platoon and find a real bat that won’t just make our lineup more lethal, but will also help the stars of our lineup see more favorable pitches. We’ve gotten close on Casey Blake and Mark DeRosa this month but nothing came of it, leaving Adrian Beltre, Ty Wiggington or Joe Crede for us to bid on (and the Giants are already moving in on Joe Crede). So what are we going to do?

Unfortunately as Twins fans we fight the internal battle of the optimist and the realist when it comes to our off-season acquisitions and realize that the optimist rarely ever wins, but half the fun is in hoping, right?Adrian Beltre is a target of the Minnesota Twins at 3B

The optimist: We take a stab at Adrian Beltre. Yes, he no-trade-claused the Twins recently, but that’s protocol for a player wanting more money in the event of a trade. Adrian Beltre has the most upside of any of the 3B out there this year and would be a huge threat in the middle of our lineup. We would have made a bigger stab at Blake or DeRosa if we thought there wasn’t something else we wanted down the road, right?

The realist: The Twins wait around a few months and hope the prices fall on somebody so they can grab them at a discount. We’ll take a hard look at Ty Wigginton and decide if we want to pay a few million extra to grab him. If we decide not to we start the season comfortably having done nothing to improve our infield and hope that the Harris/Buscher platoon can pan out.

One of these days the optimist will win a battle or two. But as our current ownership stands I wouldn’t bet on it. It’s frustrating to the Twins fan who really thinks we could put forth a World Series caliber product if given the appropriate upgrades, but I suppose that’s the fun in being a Minnesota Twins fan. Being the Davids of baseball is far more satisfying than being the Goliaths.

On the defensive side of the ball, our relief was terrible late last season and possibly cost us a division crown. Our relief was overworked and we needed a few more arms to help out. Luckily for us, last year Jose Mijares came along and nearly saved our bullpen (and he’s pitching phenomenally right now in winter ball).

With Pat Neshek out again this year, we need an 8th inning setup man for Nathan to help fill that void, as well as a few more quality arms in the bullpen throughout the season. This is going to help out guys like Guerrier who was just killed when he wasn’t given the appropriate time off in-between appearances later in the season as our relief continued to wear thinner and thinner.

Joe Mauer Has Kidney SurgerySigning guys like R.A. Dickey (most likely low impact), could still help out some of our relief later in the season when we start to overwork them. And signing Dickey to a minor league deal isn’t going to hurt anyone (although LEN3 may disagree). Hopefully there will be some more positive news coming your way next week.

In other news today:

Joe Mauer had Kidney Surgery, but it doesn’t look like it will be serious. Thank God.

The Rangers may pick up Eddie Guardado, good for him.

The White Sox are looking to deal Gavin Floyd for Brian Roberts straight up.

The Giants seem to be entering the Manny Ramirez debacle. If things keep going like they’re going we might just snag him out from everyone in early April for $15m/yr!!!



Colts-Chargers Wild Card Preview, Prediction, and Injury Updates

Email Post Email Post

Colts-Chargers Preview and PredictionWild Card weekend is upon us, with four games to try to satiate America’s insatiable appetite for the NFL. (Follow the think for a breakdown of the TV schedules, announcer lineups, and point spreads of each game this weekend.)

There is one clear marquee matchup this weekend though, and it will take place Saturday night at 8:00 in San Diego, California when the Indianapolis Colts take on the San Diego Chargers.

Why is this game the marquee matchup of the weekend?

  1. These are the two hottest teams in the NFL. The Colts started 3-4 and then won 9 straight to finish 12-4 and capture the Wild Card. The Chargers started 4-8 and then reeled off four straight wins to finish 8-8 and win the AFC West. That’s 13 straight victories between the two, and proof that I have elementary math skills.
  2. The game features superstars on both sides of the ball for each team. Peyton Manning is now a three-time MVP winner, while the Chargers have a former MVP of their own in LaDainian Tomlinson. Bob Sanders is a former NFL Defensive Player of the Year. Philip Rivers rubs some people the wrong way, but has had an outstanding season. Antonio Gates, Antonio Cromartie, Reggie Wayne, Dwight Freeney…yeah, there are stars all over the field.
  3. The Colts and Chargers have a history of playing great, meaningful games against eachother in both the regular season and the playoffs. Earlier this season, the Colts beat the Chargers 23-20 in a game that helped turn the Colts season around. They have played three times in the last two seasons, and each game has been decided by four points or less.
  4. It is possible that this could be Tony Dungy’s last game on an NFL sideline if the Colts fall short Saturday night.Peyton Manning and Colts Take on San Diego Chargers in Wild Card Game Saturday Night

There are plenty more reasons, but there is no need to state the obvious any more. Everyone knows that this will be the best game of the weekend, and I can’t wait to park myself on the couch and watch it Saturday night.

If you are looking for some solid analysis of the game, here are a few relevant links for you:

USA TODAY Colts-Chargers Preview and Prediction

Scouts, Inc Colts-Chargers Preview and Prediction

Stampede Blue – a great source for up-to-the-minute Colts news and notes

Now, let’s discuss for a minute one of the most important factors leading up to this game: injuries. The Colts have been hampered by injuries all season long, but are relatively healthy heading into this game. Oft-injured superstar SS Bob Sanders will play, as will RB Joseph Addai, although he only has one carry over the last three weeks. As of right now, only Gary Brackett is listed as out on the injury report. CB Keiwan Ratliff is questionable, but participated fully in the most recent practice.

On the San Diego side, the injury outlook is a little less clear and positive. Both Antonio Gates and LaDainian Tomlinson are questionable as of the most recent updates on the injury report. According to ProFootballTalk.com, they both have a 50-50 chance of playing. Obviously, the availability of stars like Tomlinson and Gates will have a huge impact on the game.

(Update: Just heard John Clayton say on ESPN that Tomlinson should be able to play, despite not practicing all week. Antonio Gates, however, is “more questionable.” Norv Turner was reportedly more pessimistic after the most recent practice and Gates will be a game-time decision.)

Now let’s get down to the nitty-gritty. It’s prediction time. I will come right out and say that I think the Colts are winning this game. Who do you think will win?

Who will win Saturday night's Wild Card Playoff game between the Indianapolis Colts and San Diego Chargers?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Here are my reasons for liking the Colts on Saturday night:

  1. The Colts’ superstars are healthier. Playoff games are won by stars, and with Tomlinson and Gates hindered, it is a huge advantage to a Colts team that has gotten healthy at just the right time.
  2. Who do you have more confidence in: Tony Dungy or Norv Turner? I thought so.
  3. Who do you have more confidence in: Peyton Manning or Philip Rivers? I thought so. (And let me just say, this is no disrespect to Philip Rivers, who is proving to be an outstanding quarterback. But Peyton Manning won the MVP for a reason, and he has proven more in the postseason than Rivers.)
  4. The Chargers are 3-7 against teams outside the AFC West. And remember, the AFC West sucks. If the Chargers were in any other AFC division, they most likely would not even be in the playoffs.

However, this is not going to be any type of cake walk for the Colts, regardless of whether Gates and Tomlinson play. Peyton Manning has always struggled against the Chargers defense, and the gap between Manning and Rivers is actually closer than you might think. Plus, you have to give San Diego a slight bump because of Tony Dungy Gives Colts Advantage Over Norv Turner and Chargersthe homefield advantage.

Still, in close games, I always go with the coach and QB I trust more. And regardless of whether you think Manning or Rivers is playing better right now, I don’t think anyone can argue that Tony Dungy is a better coach, and specifically a better big-game coach, than Norv Turner. For that reason in particular, I’m taking the Colts.

Colts-Chargers Prediction:

Indianapolis Colts 31 | San Diego Chargers 30

(And this, of course, means that you should go run and put money on the Chargers. I would say that my success predicting games this year has been bad, but I don’t want to overstate my abilities.)

Enjoy the game everyone, and then get ready for the Dolphins to upset the Ravens on Sunday. It’s happening.



Could Saturday’s Colts-Chargers Game Be Tony Dungy’s Last Game as Colts Head Coach?

Email Post Email Post
tony_dungy

Colts fans most likely do not want to be reminded of this, but there is a very real chance that tomorrow’s Colts-Chargers game could be last game of Tony Dungy’s illustrious head coaching career.

If the Colts lose to the Chargers.Will Tony Dungy Retire from the Colts?

And if Tony Dungy does, in fact, decide to retire.

How real is the possibility? According to a report by Ed Werder on ESPN.com, the possibility, at least, is very real.

When the Indianapolis Colts conclude their season, coach Tony Dungy intends to spend the first full week of his offseason deliberating whether to return or retire from the NFL.

“I’ve really enjoyed the season,” said Dungy, who acknowledged having three-time league MVP Peyton Manning at quarterback and a team with 12-win talent makes leaving difficult. “It was really a unique challenge to be 3-4 and then see our team really come together the way that it has to make the playoffs.”

Dungy said when he leaves the NFL he will do so with the expectation of never returning. That’s the reason he wants to take his time, preferring to make a logical choice rather than an emotional decision he might later regret.

Dungy has taken this same approach the past four years. Each time, Dungy acknowledged, he began the playoffs with the belief he would retire at the end of the postseason. But he has changed his mind each time.

There is more interesting stuff in Werder’s report if you follow the link above. As Werder reports, and as many Colts fans know, Dungy has been commuting back and from Tampa to Indianapolis so that he can watch his son Eric’s football games. This was one of the arrangements offered by Jim Irsay to convince Dungy to stay another season.

As observed by Mike Florio at Pro Football Talk, there was talk among many in the league the Colts’ 3-4 start to this season might have had something to do with the speculation that Dungy already had one foot out the door. Obviously no one is saying that now, as the Colts have won nine straight, are in the playoffs, and once again had an MVP season from Peyton Manning.

From Werder’s report, it does not necessarily sound like Tony Dungy is leaning one way or the other. I am sure that every Colts fan, and most NFL fans, would love to see Tony Dungy stay in Indianapolis. As Florio also observes, Tony Dungy is often treated with kid gloves by the media. But you know what? I think in a lot of ways that Dungy has earned it.

Tony Dungy Could Coach His Last Game Saturday for the ColtsTony Dungy is proof positive than an NFL coach does not need to spend 20 hours a day at the office, and does not need to be a surly jerk to gain the respect of his players and peers. He is, by all accounts, a good a decent man who has also received a tremendous amount of much deserved sympathy after the tragic suicide of his son a few years ago. Tony Dungy treats the media (although perhaps not the injury report) with respect, as opposed to condescension; if that earns him a little more leeway from the media, then good for him.

As many of my Indianapolis friends know, I am not a Colts fan. In fact, I grew up in Indiana hating the Colts. I grew up a Dolphins fan and have become a die-hard Browns fan over the last decade. Obviously I am not rooting for the Browns in the playoffs (what a laughable thought after this season), but I do have the Dolphins to root for. But if the Dolphins are out of it, I will officially become a Colts fan.

I would love to have Tony coach my team any day, and I cannot think of a better story (other than the Dolphins winning the Super Bowl after going 1-15 last year) than the Colts rising from 3-4 to win the Super Bowl, and then Tony Dungy riding off into the sunset, awaiting his call for the Hall of Fame.

So I sincerely hope that the Colts beat the Chargers tomorrow night, and that it is not Tony Dungy’s final game either way. If for some reason it is, Tony Dungy will forever have my respect and appreciation as a football fan for being a great coach, a great man, and a great role model. Most NFL coaches earn respect based on their wins and losses. Tony Dungy is one coach who has everyone’s respect and admiration regardless of the Ws and Ls.

The fact that Tony Dungy wins more than just about any modern coach, except for maybe Bill Belichick, is just icing on the cake. In terms of class and integrity, of course, Tony Dungy and Bill Belichick cannot even really be compared. It wouldn’t be fair to compare Bill Belichick to someone who is so obviously out of his league.

So get a W tomorrow Colts, and then a few more after that. If this is the last go around for Tony Dungy, I’d like to see it last as long as possible.